Property listing for 823 N Fletcher Ave, Fernandina Beach, FL, 32034
For SaleDuplex

$879,000

823 N Fletcher Ave, Fernandina Beach, FL, 32034

Updated Income-Producing Duplex Steps from the Beach on 75x100 Lot

4 Bed · 1,909 Sq Ft

Protected ocean views, rental income, oversized corner lot on Amelia Island

4

Beds

1,909

Sq Ft

1956

Built

0.17 acres

Lot

About 823 N Fletcher Ave

This is the rare beach-block opportunity Fernandina Beach buyers watch for: an updated, income-producing duplex sitting on an oversized 75 x 100 corner lot with protected ocean views and easy beach access just steps from your door. The two-unit layout currently yields rental income while offering immediate flexibility — live in one side and rent the other, continue as a turnkey short-term rental, convert to a single-family residence, or use the generous lot to build a new island home.

Inside the combined 1,909 finished square feet you’ll find practical systems upgrades that matter to owners and investors alike: a roof replaced in 2019, HVAC units updated in 2018/2019, and water heaters replaced within the last year. Those capital improvements reduce near-term maintenance and streamline turnovers for rental management. The four-bedroom configuration across the duplex delivers functional space and privacy for guests or tenants, while the corner orientation creates excellent cross-breeze potential and sight lines toward the ocean.

Outdoor living is the star here — the property’s wide lot gives you yard space almost unheard-of so close to the sand. Protected ocean views are preserved from vantage points on the lot, and public beach access is within a very short stroll. Whether you’re hosting friends, laying out beach gear, or contemplating a future second-story expansion to capture even broader views, the site delivers rare latitude for an Amelia Island home.

Location and versatility combine to make this listing compelling for multiple buyer types: investors seeking reliable short-term rental performance, families wanting a home with immediate income-offset potential, or buyers who want to build their forever beach residence while enjoying the island now. With its proven rental history, recent system upgrades, and a parcel size that invites imagination, 823 N Fletcher Ave is a true island holding with immediate use and long-term upside. Don’t miss the chance to own one of the more flexible, well-maintained footprints within walking distance of the Atlantic shoreline.

Home Highlights

Income-producing duplex75x100 corner lot with protected ocean viewsBeach access steps awayRoof replaced 2019AC units replaced 2018/2019Water heaters replaced within last yearFlexible use: keep as duplex, live/rent, convert or redevelop

Property Features

Interior Features

  • Two-unit duplex configuration (income-producing)
  • Combined 1,909 finished square feet
  • 4 bedrooms total
  • Updated mechanicals: AC units replaced 2018/2019
  • Water heaters replaced within last year

Exterior & Lot

  • Large corner lot, 75 ft x 100 ft (approx. 0.17 acres)
  • Protected ocean views from the lot
  • Beach access just steps away
  • Roof replaced in 2019
  • Room to expand or build a new home

Location & Neighborhood

  • On Amelia Island, Fernandina Beach address
  • Short walk to the Atlantic shoreline
  • Island lifestyle with rental and owner-occupier demand
  • Close proximity to beach access points

Walkability & Recreation

  • Walkability Rating: null — beach access is within a short stroll
  • Direct access to shore for swimming and beach activities
  • Oversized lot provides private outdoor space for recreation
  • Great starting point for island walking and bicycling routes
  • Community recreation options available on Amelia Island

Neighborhood & Location

An authentic slice of Amelia Island living, this Fernandina Beach location places you within steps of the sand and the relaxed rhythm of the shoreline. The property’s oversized corner lot and protected ocean views give you direct access to island days and evenings while maintaining proximity to the amenities that draw people to Amelia Island. Buyers here are often looking for a blend of immediate livability and long-term potential — whether that means rental income, year-round residence, or eventual redevelopment into a private beach house.

Market Insights

This property’s list price aligns directly with the independent valuation midpoint of $879,000 and a price-per-square-foot estimate of roughly $460 — data points that reflect the premium buyers place on homes closest to Amelia Island’s beaches. Coastal duplexes and near-beach properties typically attract both investors and lifestyle buyers, creating a market dynamic where income potential and location drive demand. While broader market metrics for Fernandina Beach are not provided here, the combination of limited near-sand inventory and the ability to generate rental revenue generally favors sellers for well-located multi-family assets. For buyers, this moment is attractive if you value immediate cashflow or a pathway to a single-family conversion on a rare corner lot; for investors, the recent capital improvements lower short-term carrying risk. Given the property’s recent roof and HVAC upgrades and its turnkey rental capability, buyers can expect fewer immediate capital calls than with comparable older coastal units.

AI Valuation Estimate

Low

$844K

Midpoint

$879K

High

$914K

$460/SF estimated price per square foot

65% confidence

Derived from Redfin listing LD+JSON

This is a computer-generated estimate for informational purposes only and is not an appraisal or professional valuation.

Market & Area Data

Nearby Points of Interest

  • Beach access just steps away
  • On Amelia Island, Fernandina Beach address
  • Close proximity to beach access points
  • Walkability Rating: null — beach access is within a short stroll
  • Direct access to shore for swimming and beach activities

An authentic slice of Amelia Island living, this Fernandina Beach location places you within steps of the sand and the relaxed rhythm of the shoreline. The property’s oversized corner lot and protected ocean views give you direct access to island days and evenings while maintaining proximity to the amenities that draw people to Amelia Island. Buyers here are often looking for a blend of immediate livability and long-term potential — whether that means rental income, year-round residence, or eventual redevelopment into a private beach house.

Market data is based on aggregated public records and may not reflect real-time conditions.

Are You the Agent?

Claim this property page to feature your contact info and connect directly with buyers researching this address.

  • Listing agents can add photos and list price
  • Buyer's agents can capture buyer inquiries
  • Your name, brokerage, and contact on the page
Claim This Listing — $15

One-time fee. Your info appears on this page across CompCasa.

Looking to Buy or Sell?

Connect with a licensed local agent who knows this area.

Find a Local Agent

CompCasa is a marketing and technology platform. All brokerage services are provided by licensed partners.

Request a Showing