Property listing for 753 S Horsepen Dr, Harrells, NC, 28444
For SaleSingle Family Home

$859,000

753 S Horsepen Dr, Harrells, NC, 28444

Southern Colonial Lakefront Home with Private Pier and Lanai

4 Bed · 3.5 Bath · 3,763 Sq Ft

Bay Tree Lakes gated living with water access and resort amenities

4

Beds

3.5

Baths

3,763

Sq Ft

2001

Built

2-car garage

Garage

About 753 S Horsepen Dr

This Southern Colonial stands on Horsepen Lake within the gated enclave of Bay Tree Lakes, offering private-water living without sacrificing classic architectural presence. Approaching the house you’ll notice the symmetrical façade and a two-story foyer that sets the tone: a dramatic staircase, a Juliet balcony, and broad hardwood floors that run through the principal rooms. Pocket doors open to a refined home office trimmed with handcrafted dentil molding, built-in desks and custom cabinets — a thoughtful layout for remote work or a home study.

Entertaining is effortless here. The formal dining room is expansive and sits opposite the office, while the family room centers on a fireplace with gas logs, built-ins and a sightline to the water. The kitchen is built for serious daily life and gatherings: two islands, custom cabinetry, granite countertops and a large walk-in pantry give the space both form and function. Both the kitchen and family room open onto a covered lanai that overlooks the private pier and Horsepen Lake — a quiet setting to watch waterfowl and the sweeping sunrise over the open water.

Upstairs delivers options for every household. The secluded master suite reads like a private wing with a spa-style bath, soaking tub, separate walk-in shower, double vanities and a private dressing room with separate his-and-hers closets. The upper level also includes multiple bedrooms configured for flexibility — the listing describes two en-suite bedrooms plus additional bedrooms that share a Jack-and-Jill arrangement — and a versatile bonus room that can be media space, playroom or studio.

Bay Tree Lakes enhances the property with community-scale amenities: a resort-style pool overlooking Bay Tree Lake, a cabana and clubhouse, two boat ramps, a community pier, miles of canals, walking trails, a playground, and tennis/pickleball courts. Whether you’re fishing, kayaking, swimming or enjoying a slow boat ride between lakes, the setting supports an active, water-centered lifestyle. Meticulous interior details and the private waterfront setting make this Southern Colonial a rare opportunity to own a gracious home in a guarded, amenity-rich lake community.

Home Highlights

Waterfront on Horsepen Lake with private pierGated Bay Tree Lakes community with extensive amenitiesTwo-island kitchen with granite countertopsHome office with custom built-ins and dentil moldingSecluded master suite with spa bathCovered lanai overlooking the lake3,763 sq ft of living space2-car garage

Property Features

Interior Features

  • 4 bedrooms, 3.5 bathrooms
  • Grand two-story foyer with Juliet balcony
  • Hardwood floors in main living areas
  • Home office with dentil molding, built-ins and custom cabinets
  • Formal dining room
  • Family room with built-ins and gas-log fireplace
  • Kitchen with two islands, custom cabinets and granite countertops
  • Spacious walk-in pantry
  • Secluded master suite with spa bathroom, soaking tub and double vanities
  • Versatile upstairs bonus room

Exterior & Lot

  • Waterfront on Horsepen Lake
  • Private pier
  • Covered lanai overlooking the lake
  • 2-car garage
  • Gated community setting
  • Canals connecting Bay Tree Lakes

Location & Neighborhood

  • Bay Tree Lakes gated community
  • Community clubhouse and cabana
  • Resort-style pool overlooking Bay Tree Lake
  • Two boat ramps and a community pier
  • Walking trails and playground
  • Tennis and pickleball courts

Walkability & Recreation

  • Walkability Rating: null — insufficient data for daily errands proximity
  • Direct water access: Horsepen Lake and canals for boating and fishing
  • Community pool and cabana on Bay Tree Lake
  • Walking trails within the community
  • Tennis/Pickleball courts on-site
  • Boat ramps and community pier for easy launch and storage

Neighborhood & Location

Bay Tree Lakes is a gated, family-oriented lake community built around two interconnected lakes and miles of canals. Residents enjoy a clubhouse, cabana, resort-style pool overlooking Bay Tree Lake, community pier, two boat ramps, walking trails, playground and tennis/pickleball courts. The development emphasizes outdoor recreation and a relaxed, waterfront lifestyle — ideal for boating, kayaking, fishing and neighborhood gatherings. The community’s controlled access and shared amenities create a resort-like environment while remaining quiet and residential.

Market Insights

This listing’s valuation sits at an estimated midpoint of $859,000 with a calculated price-per-square-foot of approximately $228 and a model confidence of 0.65. That midpoint matches the broker list price, positioning the home squarely within the $600K–$1M buyer bracket for this niche of waterfront residences. Specific local MLS metrics (days on market, current inventory, recent sale-to-list ratios) were not provided in the supplied data; prospective buyers and investors should request the latest Harrells/Bay Tree Lakes market reports from their agent for up-to-the-minute figures. What is clear from the property’s configuration and community amenities is that lakefront homes in gated developments often command price stability due to limited supply and specialized demand. For buyers seeking waterfront lifestyle and turnkey architectural character, this Bay Tree Lakes residence represents a compelling entry — particularly when the listing price aligns with valuation models and the home’s built-in income of lifestyle amenities reduces the need for major immediate upgrades.

Walkability & Recreation

85
Recreation

Very good recreation access: direct lake and canal frontage, community pool, boat ramps, pier, walking trails, and tennis/pickleball courts provide many on-site outdoor options for boating, fishing and active recreation.

AI Valuation Estimate

Low

$825K

Midpoint

$859K

High

$893K

$228/SF estimated price per square foot

65% confidence

Derived from Redfin listing LD+JSON

This is a computer-generated estimate for informational purposes only and is not an appraisal or professional valuation.

Market & Area Data

Nearby Points of Interest

  • Waterfront on Horsepen Lake
  • Covered lanai overlooking the lake
  • Canals connecting Bay Tree Lakes
  • Bay Tree Lakes gated community
  • Resort-style pool overlooking Bay Tree Lake
  • Walking trails and playground
  • Direct water access: Horsepen Lake and canals for boating and fishing
  • Community pool and cabana on Bay Tree Lake
  • Walking trails within the community

Bay Tree Lakes is a gated, family-oriented lake community built around two interconnected lakes and miles of canals. Residents enjoy a clubhouse, cabana, resort-style pool overlooking Bay Tree Lake, community pier, two boat ramps, walking trails, playground and tennis/pickleball courts. The development emphasizes outdoor recreation and a relaxed, waterfront lifestyle — ideal for boating, kayaking, fishing and neighborhood gatherings. The community’s controlled access and shared amenities create a resort-like environment while remaining quiet and residential.

Market data is based on aggregated public records and may not reflect real-time conditions.

Find a Local Agent

Looking to buy or sell? Connect with a licensed local agent who knows this area.

Request a Showing

Your inquiry will be connected with a licensed local real estate professional through our brokerage partner.

Are You a Local Agent?

No agency is currently featured for this market. Join the CompCasa Local Partner Program to get your brokerage placed on property pages like this one.

Learn About the Partner Program

CompCasa is a marketing and technology platform. All brokerage services are provided by licensed partners.