Property listing for 55950 Hoosier Avenue, Mishawaka, IN 46545
For SaleSingle Family Home

$160,500

55950 Hoosier Avenue, Mishawaka, IN 46545

Auction Opportunity: 1951 Ranch on a Quarter-Acre Lot

2 Bed · 1 Bath · 1,008 Sq Ft

Fixer-upper ranch near marina and top-rated schools

2

Beds

1

Baths

1,008

Sq Ft

1951

Built

0.25 acres

Lot

About 55950 Hoosier Avenue

This single-story ranch at 55950 Hoosier Avenue presents a rare auction-entry opportunity: a 1951 wood-frame home with 1,008 square feet on a generous 0.25-acre, level lot. The property’s most immediate asset is its setting — less than half a mile from Margaret H. Prickett Marina Park — placing you steps from riverfront recreation and a handful of neighborhood gathering spots such as South Bend Distillery and Saddle Up Saloon. For an investor or buyer willing to renovate, that proximity translates into tangible lifestyle and resale benefits.

Inside, the footprint is straightforward and practical: two bedrooms, one bath, and a ranch layout that keeps everything on a single level. Systems are basic but functional — forced-air gas heating is installed, while no central cooling is present, so adding air conditioning is a near-term project to consider. Roof is asphalt shingle, and the interior condition has been described as average; the home shows the typical wear of a midcentury residence and will reward a thoughtful program of updates, from cosmetic refreshes to mechanical improvements.

Outside, the quarter-acre lot opens possibilities. Room for a garden, a patio, or modest expansion is available without the constraints of a tight infill parcel. There is no attached garage; parking and storage would be addressed through renovation plans. The property’s assessed value ($98,100 in 2024) sits notably below nearby market levels, and a sales-comparison valuation places a reasonable market range between $139,000 and $182,000 (midpoint roughly $160,500), suggesting upside for an owner who invests in targeted improvements.

Location is a standout: the home is in Mishawaka’s 46545 zip code within the Penn-Harris-Madison School Corporation, where Elsie Rogers Elementary, Schmucker Middle School and Penn High School earn strong community reputations. Local dining and entertainment spots are walkable from Hoosier Avenue, while broader retail and commuter routes are quickly reachable from McKinley Highway. Because this property is listed for auction, it may appeal most to investors, flippers, or buyers comfortable navigating auction purchase and renovation timelines.

Buyers should prioritize site inspection and cost estimates: confirm the full condition of structure and systems, verify auction procedures, and factor in the expense of adding cooling and any required roof, foundation, or mechanical work. With careful due diligence, 55950 Hoosier Avenue is positioned to become a refreshed neighborhood home or a value-add investment in a community with strong schools and close-in recreation.

Home Highlights

Auction-listed — potential below-market acquisition0.25-acre level lot with expansion potentialLocated 0.4 miles from Margaret H. Prickett Marina ParkWithin Penn-Harris-Madison School CorporationAssessed value below local market estimatesBasic systems in place (forced-air gas heating)No central cooling — opportunity to add modern ACNo garage — room to build parking or storage

Property Features

Interior Features

  • Single-story ranch layout
  • 2 bedrooms, 1 full bathroom
  • Approx. 1,008 sq ft living area
  • Forced-air gas heating
  • Wood-frame construction
  • Average condition — ready for renovation

Exterior & Lot

  • 0.25-acre level lot (approx. 10,890 sq ft)
  • Asphalt shingle roof
  • No garage (opportunity to add parking or outbuilding)
  • Room for yard, patio, or modest expansion
  • Quiet residential setting

Location & Neighborhood

  • 0.4 miles to Margaret H. Prickett Marina Park
  • Nearby dining and entertainment: South Bend Distillery, Saddle Up Saloon, Indiana Tap
  • Penn-Harris-Madison School Corporation
  • Quick access to McKinley Highway

Walkability & Recreation

  • Walkability Rating: 50/100 — Some walkable amenities
  • Margaret H. Prickett Marina Park (0.4 mi) and riverfront access
  • Local restaurants and neighborhood gathering spots within a short walk
  • Neighborhood green space and room on-lot for outdoor improvements
  • Community recreation opportunities nearby

Neighborhood & Location

This section of Mishawaka blends quiet residential blocks with convenient access to riverfront recreation and local nightlife. Residents enjoy proximity to Margaret H. Prickett Marina Park for walking and boating, a small cluster of neighborhood restaurants and bars, and highly regarded Penn-Harris-Madison schools. The area is established, with midcentury homes on generous lots and easy connections to McKinley Highway for regional travel. For families and investors alike, the neighborhood offers a balance of suburban calm and nearby amenities.

Market Insights

Mishawaka’s 46545 market currently reads as a seller’s market, with Redfin data showing a median sale price around $248,000 and average days on market near 62 days. Inventory remains constrained relative to demand, so well-priced single-family homes — particularly those near strong school districts and recreational assets — continue to attract interest. This property, offered at auction and assessed well below area medians, represents a potential below-market acquisition for buyers prepared to renovate. Comparable nearby sales illustrate a range of outcomes: one nearby 3-bed sold for $44,000 in 2025 (similar condition), while another sold for $100,000 in 2023; those sales highlight volatility for distressed or renovator listings. For typical single-family residences in this corridor, buyer competition and turnover are steady; as such, investors who secure purchase financing or cash for quick renovations can often realize appreciation aligned with broader neighborhood pricing. Key buyer cautions: verify auction terms, budget conservatively for renovations (including adding cooling), and confirm final carrying costs against projected rental or resale assumptions. Given local school quality and marina access, this property appeals both to investor buyers and owner-occupants targeting long-term neighborhood value.

Nearby Schools

Elsie Rogers Elementary School

Elementary

7/10

Schmucker Middle School

Middle

8/10

Penn High School

High

10/10

Walkability & Recreation

50
Walkability
80
Recreation

Very good marina and riverfront access (Margaret H. Prickett Marina Park 0.4 miles), nearby parks and local dining; strong options for walking and casual outdoor recreation.

Investment Highlights

  • Listed for auction, potential below-market acquisition
  • Located in a desirable Mishawaka neighborhood
  • Proximity to highly rated schools and local amenities
  • Opportunity for value appreciation through renovation
  • Spacious 0.25-acre lot offering expansion potential

Key Findings

  • Assessed value of $98,100, below estimated market value
  • Built in 1951 with 1,008 square feet of living space
  • Located within 0.4 miles of Margaret H. Prickett Marina Park
  • Nearby schools rated 7/10 to 10/10 by GreatSchools
  • Median sale price in the area is $248,000 with 62 average days on market

Things to Consider

  • Property condition may require significant renovation
  • No garage or dedicated parking space
  • Heating system present, but no cooling system installed
  • Potential for unknown structural or system issues due to age

Opportunity Analysis

Auction-listed property in a desirable Mishawaka neighborhood with potential for value appreciation through renovation. Proximity to amenities and highly rated schools enhances appeal.

Potential Use Scenarios

  • Acquire at auction for below-market price
  • Invest in renovations to enhance property value
  • Consider as a rental property given proximity to schools and amenities

Risk Factors

  • Potential for unforeseen renovation costs
  • Market conditions affecting resale value post-renovation
  • Age of property may present maintenance challenges

Buyers should conduct independent due diligence before making any purchase decisions.

AI Valuation Estimate

Low

$139K

Midpoint

$161K

High

$182K

$159/SF estimated price per square foot

75% confidence

Sales comparison approach using nearby 2-bedroom homes sold within the last 12 months. Adjusted for size, condition, and lot size. Assessed value of $98,100 appears below market.

As of 2026-05-16

This is a computer-generated estimate for informational purposes only and is not an appraisal or professional valuation.

Market & Area Data

Market Trends

Area Median Price$248,000
Avg Days on Market62 days

Demographics

ZIP code 46545 has a population of approximately 27,000 as of 2022.

Nearby Points of Interest

  • Margaret H. Prickett Marina Park (0.4 mi)
  • South Bend Distillery (0.2 mi)
  • Saddle Up Saloon (0.3 mi)
  • Indiana Tap (0.3 mi)

Proximity to local dining and entertainment options, as well as recreational facilities.

School District

DistrictPenn-Harris-Madison School Corporation
ElementaryElsie Rogers Elementary School (7/10)
MiddleSchmucker Middle School (8/10)
HighPenn High School (10/10)

Market data is based on aggregated public records and may not reflect real-time conditions.

Property Details

Building Details

Year Built1951
Constructionwood frame
Stories1
Roofasphalt shingle
Heatingforced air gas
Coolingnone
Basementnone
FireplaceNo
Conditionaverage

Lot & Site

Lot Size0.25 acres (10,890 SF)
Topographylevel

Utilities

Watermunicipal
Sewermunicipal
Electricavailable
Gasavailable

Zoning & Land Use

JurisdictionCity of Mishawaka

Allowed Uses

single family residential
Current Useresidential
Assessor UseSingle Family Residential

Tax & Sale History

Tax Assessment

Total Assessed$98,100
Land$38,100
Improvements$60,000
Annual Tax (2024)$533

Sale History

2011-11-28$0

Transfer between related parties.

2005-05-06$0

Standard sale.

Are You the Listing Agent?

Claim this property page to feature your contact info, photos, and list price.

Claim This Listing — $49

One-time fee. Your info appears on this page across CompCasa.

Request a Showing

Connect with a licensed local agent in this area.

Request a Showing

Are you a buyer's agent?

Claim ZIP 55950 — $49/yr

Property details may be compiled from public records, MLS-derived data, and automated analysis. Agent claim indicates the agent has claimed this profile or confirmed representation of the property; it does not mean the agent has verified all property details.

Request a Showing