Homes/Colorado/Castle Rock/5500 Renbarger St
CompCasa Property Analysis · single_family

5500 Renbarger St

Brand-New Toll Brothers Vona — Corner Lot Backing Open Space

Luxury 5-bed, 5.5-bath home with high-end JennAir kitchen.

5 beds5.5 baths6,678 sq ftBuilt 20260.2325 acres3-car attached garage
CompCasa valuation analysis
Estimated market value
$1,325,000
Low $1,200,000 · Midpoint $1,325,000 · High $1,450,000
Confidence65%Sales comparison approach
Last recorded sale$1,325,000Mar 9, 2026
CompCasa estimate$1,325,000Mar 12, 2026
Estimate vs. last recorded sale+$0 / +0.0%
$1,200,000$1,325,000 midpoint$1,450,000
Price / sq ft$198.5
Median sale price$675,000
Avg days on market25 days
Inventory1.8 months

Estimate anchored to list price of $1,325,000; range reflects premium for new Toll Brothers construction in Crystal Valley Ranch, lot backing open space, high-end finishes, and comparable recent sales in the Castle Rock submarket (range ±~10%). Not verified via live comparable sales search.

About the property

Brand-New Toll Brothers Vona — Corner Lot Backing Open Space

Step into the Vona Mid Century Modern by Toll Brothers — a freshly completed, thoughtfully composed residence sited on a coveted west-facing corner lot that backs directly to open space. At approximately 6,678 square feet, this two-story plan delivers a generous great room anchored to a designer kitchen that was specified to perform and impress. The kitchen showcases Yorktowne Biscotti and Carriage Black cabinetry, expansive counters, and a premium JennAir appliance suite — appealing to cooks and entertainers alike.

Five bedrooms and five-and-a-half baths are arranged to provide privacy and flexible living: a main-floor bedroom/office option, private owner’s suite with spa-quality bath, and multiple guest or secondary suites upstairs. The builder equipped the home with convenient mechanicals (tankless water heater, humidification), safety devices (carbon monoxide and radon detectors), and practical features such as a sump pump for long-term protection. The full footprint includes a three-car garage and ample driveway parking for visitors.

Outside, the irrigated and professionally landscaped yard on a 10,125 SF parcel offers both the space and seclusion uncommon in newer subdivisions: the home sits as a corner anchor with mountain and open-space views from key vantage points. Finished materials and the contemporary palette deliver a warm yet sophisticated backdrop, from the cabinetry contrasts to the hardware and flooring selections.

This property is ideally positioned for buyers seeking a turnkey, high-end home within Castle Rock’s Crystal Valley Ranch master plan — close to trails, neighborhood parks, and easy access to Castle Rock’s shopping and I-25 for regional commutes. Schedule an appointment to tour and experience how the plan’s open circulation and premium finishes come together in this special lot placement.

Property details

A 2026 mid century modern on 0.23 acres.

Building

Year built2026
ConstructionWood Frame With Modern Finishes (Toll Brothers Standard)
RoofComposition Shingle (Typical New Construction)
Heatingforced air (gas) - estimated
Coolingcentral air conditioning - estimated

Site & utilities

Lot size0.2325 acres
Garage3-car attached garage
Stories2
ConditionExcellent
BasementFull
FireplaceYes
Improvement notesVona Mid Century Modern plan by Toll Brothers; designer kitchen with Yorktowne cabinetry, high-end JennAir appliances, tankless water heater, humidifier, sump pump
Lot area10,125 sq ft
TopographyLevel
FrontageWest-facing corner home site; irrigated and landscaped; backs to open space
ParkingAttached Garage And Driveway
Parking spaces6
Parking notes3-car attached garage (builder model); ample driveway and guest spaces
AccessStandard neighborhood street access; located on Renbarger St within Crystal Valley Ranch master plan
WaterPublic
SewerPublic
ElectricPublic
GasNatural Gas (Assumed)
Location & nearby

Crystal Valley Ranch

Researched nearby locations

Downtown Castle Rock (5–7 mi)
I-25 (6–8 mi)

Location

5500 Renbarger St, Castle Rock, CO 80104

View in Google Maps
Editorial neighborhood context

Crystal Valley Ranch is a family-oriented, master-planned community in Castle Rock featuring connected trails, neighborhood parks, and a mix of architectural styles. The neighborhood appeals to buyers seeking larger lots, reliable local schools, and commuter-friendly access to I-25. Retail and dining corridors are a short drive away, while open-space corridors provide everyday recreation options.

Nearby access summary

Excellent access to neighborhood trails and open space; multiple community parks within walking distance and quick drives to regional trail systems.

ElementaryCrystal Valley Elementary (Douglas RE-1) — 7/10 (estimated)
Middle schoolMesa Middle School (Douglas RE-1) — 7/10 (estimated)
High schoolCastle View High School (Douglas RE-1) — 8/10 (estimated)
School districtDouglas County School District (DCSD / RE-1)
Market context

A factual market snapshot around 5500 Renbarger St.

Median sale price$675,000
Avg days on market25 days
Inventory1.8 months
1-year appreciation400.0%
5-year appreciation1800.0%
Editorial market perspective

Castle Rock remains one of the Denver-metro’s most stable suburban markets. Demand is driven by families seeking quality schools, more square footage per dollar than the city, and easy access to regional highways. Median single-family sale prices in the area trend substantially below the price-per-square-foot of premium new construction; new builds with high-end packages and unique lots command a noticeable premium. Inventory has tightened relative to historical norms, keeping days on market modest for well-priced new inventory. For sellers, properly marketed Toll Brothers inventory attracts both local trade-up buyers and relocating professionals; for buyers, securing this property captures a rare combination of lot quality and turn-key finishes. Expect a focused marketing campaign to yield buyer interest quickly when priced in line with nearby new-construction comparables.

Zoning & land use

Planned Unit Development for single-family residential uses; lot subject to neighborhood covenants and design guidelines

Zoning

Zoning codePUD (master planned residential) — specific lot within Crystal Valley Ranch PUD
DescriptionPlanned Unit Development for single-family residential uses; lot subject to neighborhood covenants and design guidelines
JurisdictionDouglas County / Town of Castle Rock
Current useResidential
SetbacksTypical Crystal Valley Ranch setbacks and design review apply; verify with town planning

Research-indicated uses

  • Single Family Detached Residential
  • Accessory Structures Subject To HOA / PUD Rules
  • Home Occupation Subject To Local Code
Verify with the jurisdiction: Zoning, setbacks, and allowed-use summaries are research indicators—not legal advice or a determination that a specific use is permitted.
Tax & sale history

Assessment data and recorded transactions.

Assessed value is kept visually separate from the CompCasa market-value estimate.

Sale history

2026-03-09$1,325,000
2025-12-16$1,325,000
Research findings & due diligence

What the research supports — and what is still worth verifying.

Key findings

  • List price: $1,325,000 (provided by MLS).
  • Price/SF: approximately $198.5 based on 6,678 SF.
  • Lot size: 10,125 SF (0.23 acres) — corner, west-facing, irrigated and landscaped.
  • New construction year 2026; Toll Brothers Vona Mid Century Modern.
  • Property backs directly to open space which increases privacy and value premium.
Highlights & features

What stands out about this property.

Interior Features

  • Designer kitchen with Yorktowne Biscotti & Carriage Black cabinetry
  • High-end JennAir appliance package (professional-grade range & built-ins)
  • Approximately 6,678 SF with 5 bedrooms and 5.5 baths
  • Tankless water heater and whole-home humidifier
  • Vinyl flooring in main living areas for low maintenance
  • Radon and carbon monoxide detectors installed

Exterior & Lot

  • Large 10,125 SF corner lot (west-facing)
  • Backs directly to open space — enhanced privacy and views
  • Irrigated, landscaped yard with front sprinklers
  • 3-car attached garage and substantial driveway parking
  • Master-planned community with trails and neighborhood parks

Location & Neighborhood

  • Located in Crystal Valley Ranch — master-planned community
  • Easy access to Castle Rock amenities and I-25
  • Close to shopping, dining and regional trails
  • Douglas County schools (Douglas RE-1)

Walkability & Recreation

  • Walkability Rating: 45/100
  • Nearby trails, parks, and open space access
  • Short drive to downtown Castle Rock and regional retail
  • Outdoor recreation score: 85/100
Research transparency

Sources & research confidence.

See where the property research came from and how confidence varies by field.

View sources & confidence
1
Redfin (pre-scraped JSON)View source
2
MLS (REColorado / MLS Grid)
Important: This analysis is AI-assisted using pre-scraped listing data and model knowledge. It is not a formal appraisal. Verify all critical facts before making decisions.