Property listing for 5305 23rd Ave, Cape Coral, FL, 33914
For SaleSingle Family Home

$989,000

5305 23rd Ave, Cape Coral, FL, 33914

Gulf-Access 4BR Pool Home on Oversized SW Cape Lot

4 Bed · 2 Bath · 2,217 Sq Ft

Renovated 2023 — Dock, Boat Lift, Metal Roof, Heated Pool

4

Beds

2

Baths

2,217

Sq Ft

1999

Built

0.25 acres

Lot

About 5305 23rd Ave

This is a boater’s address: sited on intersecting canals with wide-water vistas, 5305 SW 23rd Ave pairs Gulf access with an oversized quarter-acre lot and a polished, fully renovated interior. The 2023 remodel transformed the home into a bright, modern retreat—9.5' ceilings, LVP flooring, recessed lighting and triple-panel stacking sliders that open the living area to waterfront poolside living. The result is a layout that feels both generous and purposeful: living areas oriented toward the water, bedrooms tucked into a split floorplan for privacy.

The heart of the home is a chef-forward kitchen finished in 2023 with soft-close cabinetry to the ceiling, stainless appliances and a dramatic 9-foot quartz waterfall island designed to anchor gatherings. The primary suite faces the canal and delivers a spa-like bath with a freestanding soaking tub, oversized tiled shower and a double vanity, plus a walk-in closet sized for two. Two full bathrooms and three additional bedrooms accommodate family, guests or a home office wing.

Outside, the property reads like a private resort. A heated pool and picture-window screened enclosure (installed 2023) sit between the house and the dock; the dock received wrapped pilings in 2023 and the boat lift has new motors (2025). Seawall protection, electric shutters for windows and doors, fenced yard with puppy pickets and recent exterior paint complete the outdoor package. Practical upgrades include a new standing-seam metal roof (2023), gutters and soffits (2024), new water heater (2025) and updated garage door motor (2023).

Location amplifies the lifestyle—just minutes from Cape Harbour, Rumrunners and The Westin for waterfront dining, weekend brunches and sunset cruises. Frequent visitors to the canal include manatees and the occasional dolphin, underscoring the rare combination of privacy and marine access. The house is being offered move-in ready; select furniture is negotiable for buyers seeking a turnkey coastal home.

Thoughtful maintenance and recent systems upgrades make this an exceptional Gulf-access offering: modern finishes, durable construction details and immediate water access combine to deliver a low-hassle, high-enjoyment Southwest Florida home that performs equally well as a primary residence or a seasonal retreat.

Home Highlights

Move-in readyFully renovated in 2023Gulf access with private dock and boat liftStanding-seam metal roof (2023)Heated pool with screened enclosure (2023)Seawall and wrapped pilings (2023)High-end kitchen with 9' quartz waterfall islandWater heater (2025); pool pump (2026); boat lift motors (2025)

Property Features

Interior Features

  • 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms
  • 2217 sq ft living area
  • Fully renovated in 2023
  • 9.5' ceilings and recessed lighting
  • LVP flooring throughout
  • Triple-panel stacking sliders to pool
  • Chef's kitchen with 9' quartz waterfall island
  • Soft-close cabinetry to ceiling
  • Stainless steel appliances
  • Spa-like primary bath with freestanding tub and large tiled shower
  • Walk-in closet

Exterior & Lot

  • Gulf access via intersecting canals
  • Dock with wrapped pilings (2023)
  • Boat lift with new motors (2025)
  • Seawall
  • Heated pool with picture-window screened enclosure (2023)
  • Pool pump (2026)
  • Oversized 0.25-acre lot
  • Fenced yard with puppy pickets
  • Standing-seam metal roof (2023)
  • Gutters and soffits replaced (2024)
  • Electric shutters for windows & doors

Location & Neighborhood

  • SW Cape Coral neighborhood
  • Minutes to Cape Harbour
  • Close to Rumrunners and The Westin
  • Easy sunset cruising and waterfront dining nearby
  • Frequent manatee sightings and occasional dolphins

Walkability & Recreation

  • Walkability Rating: 35/100 — Car-Dependent
  • Gulf-access boating and private dock
  • Heated private pool and screened enclosure
  • Minutes to Cape Harbour shops and marinas
  • Sunset cruising and waterfront dining within close driving distance
  • Community and shoreline recreation nearby

Neighborhood & Location

Southwest Cape Coral offers a relaxed marine lifestyle with direct access to the Gulf and a friendly, residential character. Nearby Cape Harbour provides boutique shopping, marina services and a string of waterfront restaurants—ideal for dining and sunset socializing. The surrounding area supports boating, fishing and casual waterfront recreation while still providing everyday conveniences within a short drive. The neighborhood attracts owners who prioritize private outdoor living, dock access and proximity to Cape Coral’s best marinas and dining destinations.

Market Insights

Available valuation data places the estimated midpoint value at $989,000 with a modeled price-per-square-foot near $446 (confidence 0.65), which aligns with the listing price. Those figures reflect the premium buyers assign to Gulf-access homes with private docks, seawalls and turnkey, modern interiors—features that reduce time-to-market and often support competitive offers. Specific local MLS metrics (days on market, active inventory) were not included in the supplied research; buyers and investors should request current Cape Coral SW market snapshots from the listing agent for up-to-the-minute DOM and absorption-rate data. In general, properties with direct Gulf access and recent, high-quality renovations—like the standing-seam metal roof (2023), new pool pump (2026), boat lift motors (2025) and major interior updates (2023)—tend to retain value and draw strong interest when inventory is limited. For sellers, this listing’s alignment with the valuation midpoint suggests pricing that is realistic for current buyers seeking immediate waterfront lifestyle and minimal deferred maintenance.

Walkability & Recreation

35
Walkability
92
Recreation

Exceptional boating and waterfront recreation with Gulf access, private dock and boat lift; minutes to Cape Harbour marinas and waterfront dining, plus a heated private pool and screened enclosure for daily outdoor living.

AI Valuation Estimate

Low

$949K

Midpoint

$989K

High

$1029K

$446/SF estimated price per square foot

65% confidence

Derived from Redfin listing LD+JSON

This is a computer-generated estimate for informational purposes only and is not an appraisal or professional valuation.

Market & Area Data

Nearby Points of Interest

Southwest Cape Coral offers a relaxed marine lifestyle with direct access to the Gulf and a friendly, residential character. Nearby Cape Harbour provides boutique shopping, marina services and a string of waterfront restaurants—ideal for dining and sunset socializing. The surrounding area supports boating, fishing and casual waterfront recreation while still providing everyday conveniences within a short drive. The neighborhood attracts owners who prioritize private outdoor living, dock access and proximity to Cape Coral’s best marinas and dining destinations.

Market data is based on aggregated public records and may not reflect real-time conditions.

Are You the Agent?

Claim this property page to feature your contact info and connect directly with buyers researching this address.

  • Listing agents can add photos and list price
  • Buyer's agents can capture buyer inquiries
  • Your name, brokerage, and contact on the page
Claim This Listing — $15

One-time fee. Your info appears on this page across CompCasa.

Looking to Buy or Sell?

Connect with a licensed local agent who knows this area.

Find a Local Agent

CompCasa is a marketing and technology platform. All brokerage services are provided by licensed partners.

Request a Showing