Sales comparison approach using recent listings and sales of similar properties in the area. Adjusted for condition and size. Income approach not applicable due to current vacancy and condition.
1887 South Side Cottage Near the Maumee River
This compact, historic cottage sits in Toledo’s South Side just steps from the Maumee River. Built in 1887, the one‑story wood‑frame house contains approximately 824 square feet of living area on a 0.1‑acre (4,300 sqft) lot with about 30 feet of frontage on Colburn Street. The property is documented as vacant and in poor condition, and it lacks a garage, basement, and dedicated on‑site parking (street parking only).
Interior systems are minimal: the home is heated with space heaters and has no central cooling. The roof is documented as shingle and the construction is wood frame. The basic layout is two bedrooms and one bathroom within a single story, with improvement notes indicating the house requires significant renovation but offers potential for customization. Municipal utilities (gas, water, sewer, electric) are available to the site.
Zoned RD6 (Duplex Residential) under City of Toledo regulations, the parcel’s allowed uses include single‑family and duplex residences as well as certain community or religious uses; conversion potential to a two‑unit configuration is noted in the research but should be verified with the local zoning office. Comparable nearby sales and rental information show a range of outcomes for similar vintage homes: proximate comps include a larger nearby property with an estimated post‑rehab value in the mid‑$60k range, and a recent nearby rental at roughly $550/month, indicating potential income scenarios after full renovation.
Important risk factors appear in the public record. The property has a documented condition of poor and the research flags significant renovation needs. Ownership details are not readily available in primary records, and the 2025 annual property tax shown in the tax data is substantially elevated, which could materially affect holding costs. Given these items — condition, tax burden, and unclear title history — prospective buyers or investors should prioritize a full inspection, title search, tax assessment review, and verification of zoning allowances before proceeding.
See the properties helping shape the valuation.
Comparable sales
- 233 SF larger
- 1 additional bedroom
- Similar lot size
- 10 years newer
- Same living area
- Similar lot size
- Same year built
A 1887 cottage on 0.1 acres.
Building
Site & utilities
South Side
Researched nearby locations
Location
527 Colburn Street, Toledo, OH 43609
The property is located in Toledo’s South Side neighborhood, a historic area with direct proximity to the Maumee River (about 0.1 mile). Nearby anchors include the Toledo Zoo (approximately 1.5 miles) and Downtown Toledo (about 2 miles), offering cultural and employment centers within short drives. The immediate area is predominantly residential. Local schools listed for the neighborhood (Waite High School and Marshall STEMM Academy) have below‑average ratings in public datasets, and demographic data indicates a stable population with modest median incomes (approx. $35,000 within 1 mile). These factors shape both family appeal and investor expectations for the local market.
The site is within immediate walking distance of the Maumee River (approximately 0.1 mile) and is about 1.5 miles from the Toledo Zoo, offering nearby outdoor and family‑oriented recreational destinations.
A factual market snapshot around 527 Colburn Street.
Duplex Residential District
Zoning
Research-indicated uses
- Single Family
- Duplex
- Community Center
- Religious Facility
Assessment data and recorded transactions.
Assessed value is kept visually separate from the CompCasa market-value estimate.
Tax assessment
Sale history
Rental references from the research record.
Context only—not an investment recommendation or guarantee of achievable rent.
Supporting lease references
- 233 SF larger
- 1 additional bedroom
What the research supports — and what is still worth verifying.
Key findings
- Built in 1887 with 2 bedrooms and 1 bathroom
- 824 square feet of living space on a 0.1-acre lot
- Current listing price of $20,000 reflects need for renovation
- Assessed land value of $175 in 2025
- Zoned RD6, allowing for single-family and duplex residences
Still worth verifying
Routine buyer due diligence items; these are not known defects.
- Confirm extent of required renovations through professional inspection
- Verify zoning regulations and potential for duplex conversion
- Assess property tax implications and potential for reassessment post-renovation
- Research ownership history and confirm current owner details
- Evaluate market conditions and potential for property appreciation
What stands out about this property.
Interior Features
- 2 bedrooms
- 1 bathroom
- 824 sq ft gross building area
- 1 story
- Heating: space heaters
- No central cooling
- No basement
- Wood‑frame construction
- Shingle roof
- Condition: poor
- No garage
- Street parking only
Sources & research confidence.
See where the property research came from and how confidence varies by field.