Property listing for 5 Myrtle Ct, Ocean Isle Beach, NC, 28469
For SaleSingle Family Home

$865,000

5 Myrtle Ct, Ocean Isle Beach, NC, 28469

Turnkey 4-Bed Coastal Retreat Steps from the Beach

4 Bed · 2.5 Bath · 1,615 Sq Ft

Fully furnished, updated home in Island Park — strong rental history

4

Beds

2.5

Baths

1,615

Sq Ft

1996

Built

About 5 Myrtle Ct

What immediately distinguishes 5 Myrtle Ct is its location: positioned directly across the street from a dedicated beach access in the coveted Island Park community, this home lets you set aside the car and head to the sand in minutes. The sellers invested more than $100,000 into recent updates, creating a low-maintenance, turnkey coastal property that functions equally well as a primary residence, weekend retreat, or an income-producing rental.

Inside, thoughtful renovations focus on durability and coastal style. All-new luxury vinyl plank flooring anchors the main living areas and bathrooms; the bathrooms themselves have been tastefully redone; and the house is being offered fully furnished, styled in bright, relaxed tones that appeal to vacationers and long-term residents alike. Mechanical upgrades include a new HVAC system, a new water heater, a newer roof, and all-new windows and exterior doors—upgrades that substantially reduce maintenance concerns for years to come.

The 1,615 finished square feet are organized for comfortable beach living: four bedrooms and two-and-a-half baths accommodate family and guests without crowding, and the layout emphasizes easy upkeep and durable finishes. Island Park’s community features extend your living space beyond the lot—two pools and a private dock on Jinks Creek provide options for kayaking, fishing, and lazy afternoons by the water. Lawn maintenance is handled by the association, letting owners spend more time enjoying the coast and less time on upkeep.

For investors, the property’s documented rental performance is compelling: gross rental receipts of $69,469 in 2023, $64,600 in 2024 and $49,296 in 2025 (seasonal peak-driven). Those figures demonstrate established demand for turnkey, beach-proximate homes. With the majority of major systems recently updated and furnishings included, 5 Myrtle Ct is ready for immediate occupancy or to enter a management program without additional upfront renovation.

Owning here means an uncomplicated coastal lifestyle: beach days on foot, community pools and creek access for water recreation, and a property that’s been modernized for comfort and rental appeal. If you want a low-fuss Ocean Isle Beach address that checks the maintenance, location, and income boxes, this home deserves a close look.

Home Highlights

Across the street from beach accessSold fully furnished — turnkeyOver $100,000 in recent improvementsNew HVAC, water heater, windows, doors, and newer roofStrong rental history with proven seasonal incomeLVP flooring and renovated bathroomsIsland Park amenities: two pools + private dock

Property Features

Interior Features

  • 4 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms
  • 1,615 finished square feet
  • All-new luxury vinyl plank (LVP) flooring in living areas and baths
  • Renovated bathrooms
  • Sold fully furnished — turnkey condition
  • In-unit laundry (washer and dryer)
  • New HVAC system
  • New water heater

Exterior & Lot

  • Across the street from dedicated beach access
  • Newer roof
  • All new exterior windows and doors
  • Community lawn maintenance included
  • Private dock access on Jinks Creek (Island Park amenity)

Location & Neighborhood

  • Island Park community — Ocean Isle Beach
  • Two community pools
  • Private dock on Jinks Creek for kayaking and fishing
  • Short distance to public beach access
  • Turnkey rental market proximity

Walkability & Recreation

  • Walkability Rating: 40/100 — Car-Dependent
  • Immediate beach access across the street
  • Private community dock on Jinks Creek
  • Two community pools for residents
  • Local beaches and coastal recreation within minutes
  • Community green space and low-maintenance yards

Neighborhood & Location

Island Park in Ocean Isle Beach offers relaxed coastal living with community-focused amenities. Residents enjoy two community pools, a private dock on Jinks Creek for paddling and fishing, and lawn maintenance handled through the association—features that simplify ownership. The neighborhood’s proximity to beach access makes it easy to prioritize outdoor time, and the overall pace is that of a small beach town where weekends center on water, family, and casual dining. Owners benefit from both seasonal rental demand and the convenience of a low-maintenance coastal lifestyle.

Market Insights

Ocean Isle Beach single-family homes that sit steps from the sand remain a specialized segment with steady demand. This property’s estimated market midpoint of $865,000 and price per square foot of roughly $536 reflect premium value for proximity to beach access and turnkey condition; the valuation confidence is moderate per the listing data. Rental revenue history shows strong gross receipts in 2023 and 2024 with a reduced but still meaningful figure in 2025—an indicator of seasonality and market variability rather than absence of demand.

While comprehensive MLS-level metrics (days on market, current active inventory) are not embedded in the provided data, the combination of recent capital improvements (new HVAC, water heater, roof, and windows/doors), included furnishings, and Island Park amenities make the home particularly attractive to buyers seeking immediate occupancy or short-term rental income. For investors, the current window favors those who want turnkey beach assets that can be quickly marketed for seasonal bookings; for owner-occupiers, the low-maintenance condition reduces near-term capital needs. Buyers should consult local MLS snapshots for the most recent inventory and DOM comparisons, but based on the property’s features and documented rental performance, 5 Myrtle Ct stands out as a competitively positioned coastal offering.

Walkability & Recreation

40
Walkability
85
Recreation

Excellent beach and water access with a dedicated beach access directly across the street, a private dock on Jinks Creek for kayaking and fishing, and two community pools for year-round enjoyment.

AI Valuation Estimate

Low

$830K

Midpoint

$865K

High

$900K

$536/SF estimated price per square foot

65% confidence

Derived from Redfin listing LD+JSON

This is a computer-generated estimate for informational purposes only and is not an appraisal or professional valuation.

Market & Area Data

Nearby Points of Interest

  • Across the street from dedicated beach access
  • Private dock access on Jinks Creek (Island Park amenity)
  • Island Park community — Ocean Isle Beach
  • Short distance to public beach access
  • Immediate beach access across the street
  • Local beaches and coastal recreation within minutes

Island Park in Ocean Isle Beach offers relaxed coastal living with community-focused amenities. Residents enjoy two community pools, a private dock on Jinks Creek for paddling and fishing, and lawn maintenance handled through the association—features that simplify ownership. The neighborhood’s proximity to beach access makes it easy to prioritize outdoor time, and the overall pace is that of a small beach town where weekends center on water, family, and casual dining. Owners benefit from both seasonal rental demand and the convenience of a low-maintenance coastal lifestyle.

Market data is based on aggregated public records and may not reflect real-time conditions.

Find a Local Agent

Looking to buy or sell? Connect with a licensed local agent who knows this area.

Request a Showing

Your inquiry will be connected with a licensed local real estate professional through our brokerage partner.

Are You a Local Agent?

No agency is currently featured for this market. Join the CompCasa Local Partner Program to get your brokerage placed on property pages like this one.

Learn About the Partner Program

CompCasa is a marketing and technology platform. All brokerage services are provided by licensed partners.