$500,000
457 Edwards Street Ext, Rutherfordton, NC 28139
Impeccable 2022 Arts & Crafts: 3BR/2BA on .73 Acre Near Downtown
3 Bed · 2 Bath · 1,810 Sq Ft
Modern Craftsman finishes, large fenced yard, minutes to hospital & downtown
3
Beds
2
Baths
1,810
Sq Ft
2022
Built
0.73 acres
Lot
Seller description references attached garage; not recorded in public scraped parking fields—verify
Garage
About 457 Edwards Street Ext
457 Edwards Street Ext is a carefully executed Arts & Crafts home completed in 2022 and sited on a rare nearly three-quarter acre fenced lot. The exterior shows striking curb appeal: a thoughtful mix of board & batten, shake and lap siding, appointed with rich wood gable brackets. The property includes a new matching storage building and a fully encapsulated tall crawlspace—practical items that reduce maintenance and add long-term value.
Inside, the layout prioritizes everyday function alongside elevated finishes. The kitchen is the heart of the home — an oversized island/bar, quartz counters, glass tile backsplash and a chimney‑style wall hood create a strong visual focal point and excellent prep/entertaining flow into the dining area and great room. French doors open the great room to a covered porch/deck, extending living outdoors across the large yard.
The private primary suite is tucked just off the main living area and offers a relaxing ensuite with a freestanding tub, dual sinks, a tile shower and an expansive walk‑in closet. Two additional bedrooms and a well‑placed full bath are on the opposite wing—ideal for guests or family. A centrally located laundry and a convenient cubby/drop zone off the entry keep day‑to‑day life organized.
Practical benefits include the fenced yard, a new storage building, and modern systems expected in a 2022 build. Location is a standout: minutes to Rutherford Regional Hospital, quick access to US‑74, and under 30 minutes to I‑40 and I‑26 for regional connectivity. Whether you’re seeking a move‑in ready family home or a long-term hold with strong local appeal, this property combines style, substance and a highly usable lot.
Home Highlights
Property Features
Interior Features
- 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths
- Open-plan great room with French doors to covered porch/deck
- Kitchen with large island/bar, quartz countertops, glass tile backsplash
- Chimney-style wall hood
- Primary ensuite with freestanding tub, tile shower, dual sinks and walk-in closet
- Centrally located laundry and mud/cubby drop zone
Exterior & Lot
- Generous .73-acre (31,798 SF) lot — fenced yard
- New matching storage building
- Mixed exterior siding: board & batten, shake, and lap
- Encapsulated tall crawlspace
- Covered porch/deck for indoor/outdoor living
Location & Neighborhood
- Minutes to downtown Rutherfordton (shops & restaurants)
- Close proximity to Rutherford Regional Hospital (approx. 1–3 miles)
- Convenient to US‑74; under 30 minutes to I‑40/I‑26 for regional access
- Quiet residential neighborhood with foothills character
Walkability & Recreation
- Walkability Rating: 45/100
- Nearby parks and green spaces within short drive
- Easy access to foothills trails and outdoor recreation in the broader region
Neighborhood & Location
This section of Rutherfordton offers a small-town foothills lifestyle with a mix of newer builds and well-maintained older homes. Downtown Rutherfordton hosts independent shops, cafes and community events; the neighborhood feels residential and quiet while providing fast access to essential services including Rutherford Regional Hospital. Buyers here tend to value privacy, land, and convenient regional access.
Market Insights
Rutherfordton remains a small-market environment where newer, well-finished construction commands a premium over older stock. In 2026 buyers are prioritizing turnkey single-story homes with outdoor space and low-maintenance systems—advantages this home provides. Inventory for homes in the $400K–$550K range locally is tighter relative to lower-priced tiers, which supports pricing in the mid-$400Ks to low-$500Ks for quality new builds. With proximity to the regional hospital and direct access to US‑74, expect steady interest from healthcare professionals, families, and buyers relocating from larger NC metros seeking a foothills lifestyle. Days on market for comparable new/near-new homes often run below the town average when marketed aggressively and with clear utility/garage details.
Nearby Schools
Rutherford County Schools (assigned schools to be verified)
District · Varies by assignment
Rutherfordton Elementary (approx.)
Elementary · ≈1–3 mi (verify)
Rutherford County Middle / R-S Middle (approx.)
Middle · ≈3–6 mi (verify)
Rutherford County High School (approx.)
High · ≈5–10 mi (verify)
Walkability & Recreation
Property provides easy access to nearby parks, open space and foothills trails; large private lot supports yard activities and small-scale gardening.
Investment Highlights
- New construction (2022) with modern, low-maintenance finishes
- Large .73-acre professionally fenced lot with new storage building
- Encapsulated tall crawlspace reduces moisture and maintenance risk
- Open plan with strong indoor/outdoor connection via covered porch/deck
- Close proximity to Rutherford Regional Hospital and downtown
Key Findings
- 3 bed / 2 bath, 1,810 SF built in 2022; listed for $500,000
- Large 0.73-acre lot (31,798 SF) with fenced yard and storage building
- Interior finishes include quartz counters, island, glass tile backsplash, freestanding tub, tile shower
- Seller reports encapsulated crawlspace—positive for long-term durability
- Listing active on CarolinaMLS/Redfin with 2 days on market at time of scrape
Things to Consider
- Parking/garage status unclear in public record—verify actual garage presence and capacity
- Exact utility connections (public water/sewer vs. well/septic) not recorded—verify
- Precise school assignments and ratings must be confirmed with district
Opportunity Analysis
Buyers seeking a low-maintenance, nearly-new single-story home with sizable private yard and high-quality finishes should see this as a ready primary residence with good resale upside in the local market. Investors targeting short-term flips will face a smaller pool of buyers at this price point in Rutherfordton; long-term owners will benefit from the quality build and low near-term capital needs.
Potential Use Scenarios
- Owner-occupant purchase to capture lifestyle benefits and minimize holding costs
- If investor, market as premium rental to healthcare professionals (near hospital) or young families
- Verify garage and utility details quickly; clear these in marketing copy to prevent buyer friction
Risk Factors
- Narrow buyer pool at $500K price point in small-town market
- Unverified infrastructure items (septic vs. sewer, garage) could affect offers
- Market sensitivity to regional employment and interest-rate conditions
Buyers should conduct independent due diligence before making any purchase decisions.
AI Valuation Estimate
Low
$475K
Midpoint
$500K
High
$525K
$276/SF estimated price per square foot
Estimate anchored to the listed price ($500K) and property characteristics (3 BR, 2 BA, 1,810 SF, built 2022) plus market knowledge for Rutherford County. No live MLS comparable sales search performed.
As of 2026-03-11
This is a computer-generated estimate for informational purposes only and is not an appraisal or professional valuation.
Market & Area Data
Market Trends
Demographics
Rutherfordton is a small, stable foothills community attracting buyers seeking quieter small-town living with access to larger employment centers in the region. Recent new-construction and renovation activity has lifted price per square foot for modern builds.
Nearby Points of Interest
- Rutherford Regional Hospital (≈1-3 miles)
- Downtown Rutherfordton (≈1-2 miles)
Short drive to Rutherford Regional Hospital, local shops and restaurants in downtown Rutherfordton, and convenient connectivity to US-74. Regional access to I-40 and I-26 within ~30 minutes.
School District
Market data is based on aggregated public records and may not reflect real-time conditions.
Property Details
Building Details
Lot & Site
Utilities
Zoning & Land Use
Allowed Uses
Tax & Sale History
Tax Assessment
Are You the Listing Agent?
Claim this property page to feature your contact info, photos, and list price.
Claim This Listing — $49One-time fee. Your info appears on this page across CompCasa.
Request a Showing
Connect with a licensed local agent in this area.
Request a ShowingAre you a buyer's agent?
Claim ZIP 28139 — $49/yrProperty details may be compiled from public records, MLS-derived data, and automated analysis. Agent claim indicates the agent has claimed this profile or confirmed representation of the property; it does not mean the agent has verified all property details.