Property listing for 4291 US Route 35, La Porte, Indiana 46350
For SaleSingle Family Home

$1,300,000

4291 US Route 35, La Porte, Indiana 46350

15.87-Acre Contemporary Estate with Pool, Greenhouse, Pole Barn

4 Bed · 6 Bath · 6,632 Sq Ft

Private La Porte retreat minutes from Pine Lake and downtown

4

Beds

6

Baths

6,632

Sq Ft

2004

Built

15.87 acres

Lot

3.5-car attached

Garage

About 4291 US Route 35

Drive down a private, tree-lined entrance off US Route 35 and arrive at a contemporary residence set deliberately on 15.87 wooded acres—where scale, utility, and comfort are all built to an elevated standard. This 6,632-square-foot home (2004) balances expansive living areas with highly functional service spaces: soaring ceilings, a vaulted sunroom, a studio loft with its own bath and balcony, plus a dedicated home office for remote work or concentrated projects. Multiple fireplaces anchor principal rooms and a series of large windows frame the surrounding treescape.

Entertain with ease: a backyard patio is appointed with a built-in gas grill and a traditional wood-burning oven, while the heated in-ground pool invites summer days with ample deck space and privacy. The property includes a heated greenhouse for year-round growing and a massive, climate-controlled pole barn suitable for hobbies, equipment storage, or light agricultural use. Practical touches such as a full finished basement with a kitchenette and a reinforced safe room add real-world value for multi-use living and storage.

The primary circulation of the house connects gracious public rooms to intimate private wings. A studio loft—ideal for guests, an artist’s retreat, or an in-law suite—offers a private balcony and bath. The sunroom’s vaulted ceiling gives an airy, open feeling without sacrificing warmth. Systems are robust: well water, septic, 200+ amp electrical service with generator provision, forced-air natural gas heating, and central air. A 3.5-car attached garage provides convenient vehicle and gear access to the basement.

Beyond the house itself, the land invites possibilities: hobby farming, equestrian pursuits, or simply preserving a private wooded setting. Pine Lake is roughly 2.5 miles away for boating and fishing, and downtown La Porte’s shops and services are about 3 miles from the driveway. With an assessed value that trails the market and recent valuation analysis placing competitive pricing between $1.25M–$1.35M, this estate presents a rare offering for buyers seeking privacy, flexible acreage, and turnkey amenities.

For a private showing or questions about maintenance history for the pool, greenhouse, and pole barn, please contact listing agent Elisabeth Brannon at (219) 512-5143 or nikola.trajceski@example.com for co-listing coordination. Serious buyers will appreciate the combination of scale, finish, and location this property delivers.

Home Highlights

Move-in readyHeated in-ground poolHeated greenhouseClimate-controlled pole barn3.5-car attached garage with basement accessFull finished basement with kitchenetteStudio loft with private bath and balconySunroom with vaulted ceilingsWraparound front porchPrivate 15.87-acre wooded parcel

Property Features

Interior Features

  • 6,632 sq ft living area
  • 4 bedrooms; 4 full baths + 2 half baths (6 total)
  • Full finished basement with kitchenette
  • Studio loft with private bath and balcony
  • Sunroom with vaulted ceilings
  • Dedicated home office
  • Multiple fireplaces
  • Reinforced basement safe room
  • Central air and forced-air natural gas heating
  • 200+ amp electrical service and generator-ready

Exterior & Lot

  • 15.87-acre wooded lot with private tree-lined driveway
  • Heated in-ground pool
  • Backyard patio with built-in gas grill and wood-burning oven
  • Heated greenhouse
  • Massive heated and cooled pole barn
  • 3.5-car attached garage with direct basement access
  • Wraparound front porch
  • Well water and septic systems

Location & Neighborhood

  • Approximately 2.5 miles to Pine Lake
  • About 3 miles to Downtown La Porte
  • LaPorte Community School Corporation
  • La Porte Municipal Airport ~4 miles
  • Private, rural setting with convenient access to regional amenities

Walkability & Recreation

  • Walkability Rating: 30/100 — Car-Dependent
  • Pine Lake access and recreational opportunities (2.5 miles)
  • Downtown La Porte shops and services within a short drive (3 miles)
  • Nearby open acreage and wooded parcels for outdoor enjoyment
  • La Porte Municipal Airport nearby (4 miles)

Neighborhood & Location

This property sits on the edge of La Porte’s rural landscape while remaining minutes from downtown conveniences. Residents enjoy quick access to Pine Lake’s recreational options and local dining, shopping, and services in La Porte’s compact downtown. The area is serviced by the LaPorte Community School Corporation; elementary and middle schools in the district earn above-average ratings while the high school ranking is more modest. Quiet country roads, wooded parcels, and nearby open space define the locale—appealing to buyers seeking privacy without sacrificing proximity to community amenities and regional connections.

Market Insights

This segment of LaPorte County currently reads as a balanced market with pockets of demand for distinctive properties. Inventory sits at roughly 3.2 months—near equilibrium—while the area’s median sale price is about $250,000. Short-term appreciation is modest (approximately 3% year-over-year) with a stronger five-year trend of near 15% appreciation, indicating steady, long-term value growth. Average days on market across the broader area is near 45 days; luxury and atypical estates such as this one often require a longer marketing period because their buyer pool is more specialized. Comparable-sales data are limited for properties with acreage and extensive amenity packages, so active pricing strategies and targeted regional marketing are critical.

For sellers: this is a good time to showcase uniqueness—quality photography, floor plans, and outreach to buyers from Chicago and northwest Indiana will accelerate interest. For buyers: a property with a market valuation range of $1.25M–$1.35M, assessed value materially lower, and strong amenity set represents a targeted opportunity—especially for buyers who value privacy, on-site systems, and multiple outbuildings. Expect negotiation windows to be realistic; financing and inspection contingencies should reflect the property’s well systems, septic, and specialized improvements. Overall, the market supports a disciplined sale process with emphasis on the estate’s rare combination of acreage, pool, greenhouse, and pole barn.

Nearby Schools

F. Willard Crichfield Elementary School

Elementary

8/10

Kesling Intermediate School

Middle

6/10

LaPorte High School

High

4/10

Walkability & Recreation

30
Walkability
75
Recreation

Very good access to outdoor recreation with Pine Lake just 2.5 miles away for boating and fishing, nearby wooded acreage for private walks, and regional green spaces and airport access within a short drive.

Investment Highlights

  • Secluded 15.87-acre estate with luxury amenities
  • Heated in-ground pool, greenhouse, and pole barn with HVAC
  • Proximity to Pine Lake (2.5 miles) and downtown La Porte (3 miles)
  • Significant appreciation since 2010 purchase at $555,000
  • Potential for agricultural or equestrian use

Key Findings

  • Assessed value of $609,500 appears below market
  • Last sold in 2010 for $555,000
  • Located within LaPorte Community School Corporation
  • Zoned for single-family residential use with potential for accessory structures
  • Luxury properties in area may experience longer days on market

Things to Consider

  • High school rating of 4/10 may impact family buyer interest
  • Luxury property may have longer time on market due to niche buyer pool
  • Maintenance of extensive amenities (pool, greenhouse, pole barn) may require significant upkeep

Opportunity Analysis

Unique luxury estate offering privacy, extensive amenities, and significant appreciation potential in a balanced market.

Potential Use Scenarios

  • Ideal for buyers seeking a private retreat with modern conveniences
  • Potential for agricultural or equestrian use given acreage and facilities
  • Consideration for long-term appreciation in a steadily growing market

Risk Factors

  • Potential longer time on market due to niche buyer pool
  • Maintenance costs associated with extensive amenities
  • High school rating may impact appeal to families with school-aged children

Buyers should conduct independent due diligence before making any purchase decisions.

AI Valuation Estimate

Low

$1250K

Midpoint

$1300K

High

$1350K

$196/SF estimated price per square foot

85% confidence

Sales comparison approach using recent listings and sales of similar luxury estates in La Porte County. Adjusted for acreage, amenities, and condition. Assessed value of $609,500 appears below market.

As of 2026-03-11

This is a computer-generated estimate for informational purposes only and is not an appraisal or professional valuation.

Market & Area Data

Market Trends

Area Median Price$250,000
Avg Days on Market45 days
Inventory3.2 months
1-Year Appreciation+3.0%

Demographics

Population (1 mi)1,500
Median Income (1 mi)$65,000

Stable rural community with modest growth. Median home values in La Porte County have appreciated approximately 15% over the past 5 years.

Nearby Points of Interest

  • Pine Lake (2.5 mi)
  • Downtown La Porte (3 mi)
  • La Porte Hospital (3.5 mi)
  • La Porte Municipal Airport (4 mi)

Secluded estate with proximity to Pine Lake, offering recreational opportunities. Convenient access to downtown La Porte amenities and services.

School District

DistrictLaPorte Community School Corporation
ElementaryF. Willard Crichfield Elementary School (8/10)
MiddleKesling Intermediate School (6/10)
HighLaPorte High School (4/10)

Market data is based on aggregated public records and may not reflect real-time conditions.

Property Details

Building Details

Year Built2004
Constructioncement siding
Stories2
Roofshingle
Heatingforced air, natural gas
Coolingcentral air
Basementfull finished
FireplaceYes
Conditionexcellent

Lot & Site

Lot Size15.87 acres (691,253 SF)
Topographywooded
Parkingattached_garage_and_driveway
Parking Spaces3
FrontagePrivate, tree-lined driveway from US Route 35

Utilities

Waterwell
Sewerseptic
Electric200+ Amp Service, Generator, Circuit Breakers
Gasnatural gas

Zoning & Land Use

Zoning Coderesidential
DescriptionSingle Family Residential
JurisdictionLaPorte County

Allowed Uses

single familyaccessory structuresagricultural uses
Current Useresidential
Assessor UseSingle Family Residential

Tax & Sale History

Tax Assessment

Total Assessed$609,500
Land$188,200
Improvements$421,300
Annual Tax (2024)$7,340

Sale History

2010-09-03$555,000

$83.68/SF

Arm's length transaction

2004-06-03$99,000

$14.93/SF

Land purchase prior to construction

Are You the Listing Agent?

Claim this property page to feature your contact info, photos, and list price.

Claim This Listing — $49

One-time fee. Your info appears on this page across CompCasa.

Request a Showing

Connect with a licensed local agent in this area.

Request a Showing

Are you a buyer's agent?

Claim ZIP 46350 — $49/yr

Property details may be compiled from public records, MLS-derived data, and automated analysis. Agent claim indicates the agent has claimed this profile or confirmed representation of the property; it does not mean the agent has verified all property details.

Request a Showing