$199,000
3 Bed · 2 Bath · 2,721 Sq Ft
Historic character, big porch, and room to expand — priced at $199,000
3
Beds
2
Baths
2,721
Sq Ft
1928
Built
0.75 acres
Lot
Carport
Garage
This is the kind of Southern farmhouse that rewards anyone who values original craftsmanship. At 419 E Hill St the first thing you notice is the deep 12-foot wraparound front porch — wide enough for rocking chairs and long conversation. The house sits on a generous ¾-acre corner parcel that gives you room for a garden, workshop, garage, or a future pool, all set back from the street beneath mature shade trees.
Step inside and the period details are everywhere: soaring 11-foot ceilings, original hardwood floors that run through the main rooms, oversized windows, and finely carved door moldings. Three sets of classic pocket doors define flexible living spaces while functioning transoms over interior doors keep air moving throughout the layout. The main level delivers three bedrooms and two bathrooms, with rooms sized and proportioned exactly as older homes were meant to be — gracious, welcoming, and full of presence.
This property also presents a clear upside: an unfinished second floor that could add roughly 1,300 square feet of living area, and an unfinished basement that provides storage or workshop space. The home is being offered as-is and currently lacks central heating and air, which gives a buyer latitude to design modern mechanical systems that respect the historic bones while bringing the home up to contemporary comfort standards.
Out back, a large screened porch expands your living area into the landscape and offers peaceful views across the lot. Practical conveniences include a covered carport with easy access to the front door. Whether you are an investor with a restoration vision, a homeowner who wants a historic house to update carefully, or someone seeking a property with real expansion potential, this 1928 farmhouse offers rare character and a clear path to value. Homes with this level of original detail rarely remain available in Warsaw; at this price, the next chapter is wide open.
East Hill Street sits in a quiet, residential portion of Warsaw where older homes and gracious lots create a strong neighborhood character. Residents value small-town rhythms — local civic events, independent businesses in nearby downtown, and the short drives to schools and county services. The block offers a mix of historic houses and modest modern updates; yards tend to be generous, making this part of town attractive to buyers who want outdoor space, privacy, and room for expansion without leaving municipal convenience.
This listing price aligns closely with the property's automated valuation midpoint of $199,000 and a price-per-square-foot estimate of about $73, making it competitively positioned for buyers targeting historic homes in small-town eastern North Carolina. Unique older homes — especially those needing mechanical upgrades or renovation — typically spend longer on market than turnkey listings, creating opportunity for buyers who can manage improvements. Because this property lacks central HVAC and includes unfinished upper-floor and basement space, it will appeal to value-focused buyers and local renovators looking to capture equity through targeted upgrades. Inventory in smaller towns can fluctuate rapidly, so buyers should monitor local MLS feeds for comparable historic listings. For sellers, a well-documented scope of work and repair estimates for HVAC and second-floor conversion can accelerate offers; for buyers, a pre-inspection and contractor bids will clarify total investment. In short: this is a market where an informed buyer who understands renovation timelines and costs can find meaningful opportunity.
Moderate outdoor access: generous private yard and screened porch for daily activity; regional parks and outdoor recreation are a short drive away for hiking, fishing, and community sports.
Low
$191K
Midpoint
$199K
High
$207K
$73/SF estimated price per square foot
Derived from Redfin listing LD+JSON
This is a computer-generated estimate for informational purposes only and is not an appraisal or professional valuation.
East Hill Street sits in a quiet, residential portion of Warsaw where older homes and gracious lots create a strong neighborhood character. Residents value small-town rhythms — local civic events, independent businesses in nearby downtown, and the short drives to schools and county services. The block offers a mix of historic houses and modest modern updates; yards tend to be generous, making this part of town attractive to buyers who want outdoor space, privacy, and room for expansion without leaving municipal convenience.
Market data is based on aggregated public records and may not reflect real-time conditions.
Looking to buy or sell? Connect with a licensed local agent who knows this area.
Request a ShowingYour inquiry will be connected with a licensed local real estate professional through our brokerage partner.
No agency is currently featured for this market. Join the CompCasa Local Partner Program to get your brokerage placed on property pages like this one.
Learn About the Partner ProgramCompCasa is a marketing and technology platform. All brokerage services are provided by licensed partners.