Homes/Colorado/Fort Collins/409 East Prospect Road
CompCasa Property Analysis · single_family

409 East Prospect Road

Craftsman Bungalow with Finished Basement and Garden Retreat

Remodeled 4BR/3BA near CSU with ADU potential and detached office

4 beds3 baths2,648 sq ftBuilt 19410.26 acres2-car detached
CompCasa valuation analysis
Estimated market value
$1,050,000
Low $1,000,000 · Midpoint $1,050,000 · High $1,100,000
Confidence85%Sales comparison approach
Last recorded sale$245,000Oct 30, 2006
Assessed value$42,1302024 assessment
CompCasa estimate$1,050,000Mar 6, 2026
Estimate vs. last recorded sale+$805,000 / +328.6%
$1,000,000$1,050,000 midpoint$1,100,000
Price / sq ft$396.53
Median sale price$500,000
Avg days on market30 days
Inventory2.5 months

Sales comparison approach using recent listings and sales in the area. Adjusted for property size, condition, and unique features. Income approach considered due to potential for rental income from finished basement and ADU potential.

About the property

Craftsman Bungalow with Finished Basement and Garden Retreat

This is not a typical bungalow — 409 East Prospect Road pairs classic 1941 craftsmanship with thoughtful modern upgrades and a rare, flexible footprint just half a mile from Colorado State University. From the street you’ll notice the generous 0.26-acre lot and expansive driveway that can hold up to ten cars; step inside to refinished hardwood floors and a remodeled main level where a high-end kitchen anchors everyday life. Recent work includes a newly added bathroom and a kitchen renovation designed for durability and everyday comfort.

Downstairs, the finished basement changes the conversation about use and value: it has its own private entrance, full kitchen, laundry, and independent heating. That configuration supports multigenerational living, long-term rental, short-term stays, or a separate work/live arrangement without sacrificing privacy. On the garage level, a two-car detached structure has been finished into an office space — perfect for remote work, clients, or a studio — while the lot’s greenhouse and thriving garden offer berries, Colorado cherries, and room to expand hobby gardening.

Practical systems include forced-air heating, ceiling fans, and a tile roof, and the home’s wood-frame construction has been maintained in good condition. LMN (Low Density Mixed-Use Neighborhood) zoning creates optionality: accessory dwelling unit (ADU) potential gives investors and expanding families a clear path to add value. The property’s location is hard to overstate: 0.5 miles to CSU, 1.5 miles to Historic Old Town Fort Collins, and moments from Spring Creek Trail and neighborhood parks.

Offered at $1,050,000, the house balances move-in readiness with strategic upside. Buyers should note the home’s 1941 origin — while it has been thoughtfully renovated, older homes can have deferred maintenance items to address. Whether you are drawn to the separate-living basement, the detached office garage, the urban-adjacent garden, or the development possibilities under LMN zoning, this property is a compelling blend of character and contemporary utility. Contact the listing agent to schedule a tour and review inspection and permit records for the recent renovations.

Comparable evidence

See the properties helping shape the valuation.

Comparable sales

01Sold price$485,000
Property address4525 E Prospect Rd, Fort Collins, CO 80525
3 bed2 bath1,820 sq ftBuilt 19730.5 mi10,000 sq ft lot$266/SF
Sold Jul 16, 2025
Subject difference
  • 828 SF smaller
  • 1 fewer bedroom
  • 1 fewer bathroom
  • 1,287 SF smaller lot
  • 32 years newer
Research comparison noteSmaller home with fewer bedrooms; sold in 2025
02Sold price$2,100,000
Property address947 E Prospect Rd, Fort Collins, CO 80525
0.8 mi
Sold Apr 13, 2023
Research comparison noteSignificantly higher sale price; details on property size and features not available
03Sold price$118,000
Property address1048 E Prospect Rd, Fort Collins, CO 80525
3 bed2 bath1,639 sq ftBuilt 19710.9 mi10,000 sq ft lot$72/SF
Sold Oct 1, 1997
Subject difference
  • 1,009 SF smaller
  • 1 fewer bedroom
  • 1 fewer bathroom
  • 1,287 SF smaller lot
  • 30 years newer
Research comparison noteOlder sale; smaller home with fewer bedrooms
Comp methodology: Comparable sales within 1 mile were considered, focusing on properties with similar size and features. Limited recent sales data available; adjustments made for differences in size, condition, and amenities.
Property details

A 1941 craftsman bungalow on 0.26 acres.

Building

Year built1941
ConstructionWood Frame
RoofTile
Heatingforced air
Coolingceiling fan(s)

Site & utilities

Lot size0.26 acres
Garage2-car detached
Stories2
ConditionGood
BasementFinished
FireplaceNo
Improvement notes4 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, refinished hardwood floors, remodeled main level and kitchen, finished basement with private entrance, kitchen, laundry, and independent heating
Lot area11,287 sq ft
TopographyLevel
FrontageFrontage on East Prospect Road
ParkingDetached Garage And Driveway
Parking spaces12
Parking notes2-car detached garage with finished office space; expansive 10-car driveway
AccessStandard residential driveway from East Prospect Road
WaterMunicipal
SewerMunicipal
ElectricCity Of Fort Collins
GasXcel Energy
Location & nearby

Old Prospect

Researched nearby locations

Colorado State University (0.5 mi)
Historic Old Town Fort Collins (1.5 mi)
Spring Creek Trail (0.3 mi)
Edora Park (1.2 mi)

Location

409 East Prospect Road, Fort Collins, CO 80525

View in Google Maps
Editorial neighborhood context

Old Prospect combines residential calm with immediate access to university life and Old Town’s restaurants and events. The block-level feel is anchored by mature yards, bike-friendly streets, and proximity to Spring Creek Trail for daily recreation. Families value nearby O'Dea Elementary and Fort Collins High, while students and faculty appreciate easy walks to campus. Local weekend routines often include farmers markets, coffees in Old Town, and trail runs, offering an urban-adjacent lifestyle without dense congestion.

Nearby access summary

Excellent trail access with Spring Creek Trail 0.3 miles away, Edora Park within 1.2 miles, easy bike access to Old Town, and campus recreation amenities nearby.

ElementaryO'Dea Elementary School (8/10)
Middle schoolLesher Middle School (5/10)
High schoolFort Collins High School (8/10)
School districtPoudre R-1 School District
Market context

A factual market snapshot around 409 East Prospect Road.

Median sale price$500,000
Avg days on market30 days
Inventory2.5 months
1-year appreciation5.0%
5-year appreciation25.0%
Editorial market perspective

Fort Collins near CSU remains a seller-favored market: inventory sits around 2.5 months, average days on market about 30, and neighborhood median sale prices near $500,000. Short-term trends show modest appreciation (approximately 5% year-over-year and roughly 25% over five years) as demand concentrates on walkable, university-adjacent neighborhoods. Single-family homes with independent living spaces—finished basements, ADU potential, or detached studio/offices—are especially sought after because they deliver rental flexibility and lifestyle separation for multi-generational households. Recent comparable sales within a mile include smaller, updated homes in the mid-$400k range and outliers in the higher end; these underscore that lot, finished square footage, and permitted updates drive wide price dispersion. For buyers, limited supply means competitive offers are common; for sellers, properties with income potential or development upside (like LMN-zoned lots) often achieve premiums. Given this home’s finished basement with private entrance, detached office, greenhouse, and proximity to CSU and Old Town, it occupies a strong position in the current market. Verify permits and systems during due diligence; buyers who move quickly with pre-approval or proof-of-funds will be the most competitive.

Zoning & land use

Low Density Mixed-Use Neighborhood

Zoning

Zoning codeLMN
DescriptionLow Density Mixed-Use Neighborhood
JurisdictionCity of Fort Collins
Assessor useSingle Family Residential
Current useResidential
SetbacksSubject to City of Fort Collins LMN zoning regulations

Research-indicated uses

  • Single Family
  • Accessory Dwelling Unit
  • Home Occupation
Verify with the jurisdiction: Zoning, setbacks, and allowed-use summaries are research indicators—not legal advice or a determination that a specific use is permitted.
Tax & sale history

Assessment data and recorded transactions.

Assessed value is kept visually separate from the CompCasa market-value estimate.

Tax assessment

Assessed land$2,680
Assessed improvements$39,450
Total assessed$42,130
Assessment year2024
Annual property tax$3,689
Tax year2024

Sale history

2006-10-30$245,000 · $92.52/SF
Research findings & due diligence

What the research supports — and what is still worth verifying.

Key findings

  • Built in 1941 with 2,648 SF of living space on a 0.26-acre lot
  • Current listing price: $1,050,000
  • Assessed value (2024): $42,130; annual property tax: $3,689
  • Zoned LMN, allowing for flexible use including potential ADU
  • Proximity to CSU and Old Town Fort Collins enhances desirability

Still worth verifying

Routine buyer due diligence items; these are not known defects.

  • Confirm lot dimensions and boundaries
  • Verify renovation permits were properly obtained
  • Assess condition of roof and HVAC systems
  • Review potential for ADU development under LMN zoning
  • Professional home inspection
Highlights & features

What stands out about this property.

Interior Features

  • 4 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms
  • 2,648 SF finished living area
  • Remodeled main level and kitchen with high-end appliances
  • Refinished hardwood floors
  • Finished basement with private entrance, full kitchen, laundry, and independent heating
  • Newly added bathroom
  • Forced air heating; ceiling fans

Exterior & Lot

  • 0.26-acre lot (approx. 11,287 SF)
  • 2-car detached garage with finished office space
  • Expansive driveway with parking for up to 10 cars
  • Greenhouse and established garden (berries and Colorado cherries)
  • Tile roof
  • Level lot with frontage on East Prospect Road
  • LMN zoning — accessory dwelling unit (ADU) possible

Location & Neighborhood

  • 0.5 miles to Colorado State University
  • 1.5 miles to Historic Old Town Fort Collins
  • Walking distance to Spring Creek Trail (0.3 miles)
  • Easy access to dining, shops, and campus events
  • Poudre R-1 School District

Walkability & Recreation

  • Walkability Rating: 68/100 — Some errands and campus amenities within walking distance
  • Nearby parks and green spaces: Spring Creek Trail (0.3 mi), Edora Park (1.2 mi)
  • Hiking and biking trails within immediate area
  • Golf courses: (not specified in provided data)
  • Running/walking paths along Spring Creek Trail
  • Community recreation facilities accessible in Fort Collins and CSU
Research transparency

Sources & research confidence.

See where the property research came from and how confidence varies by field.

View sources & confidence
1
MLS listing for 409 E Prospect RdView source
2
Property details and tax historyView source
3
Zillow listing with property featuresView source
4
Comparable sale at 4525 E Prospect RdView source
5
Comparable sale at 947 E Prospect RdView source
6
Comparable sale at 1048 E Prospect RdView source
7
City of Fort Collins zoning informationView source
8
Larimer County Assessor's OfficeView source
Important: This analysis is AI-assisted and may contain inaccuracies. It is not a formal appraisal. Verify all critical facts with primary records, licensed professionals, and on-site inspection before making purchase decisions.