Sales comparison approach using recent sales of similar properties in the Old Wildlife Club and surrounding Lake James communities. Adjustments made for lot size, construction year, and amenities. Income approach not applicable due to owner-occupied status.
Stunning 2021 Mountain Retreat with Lake James Access
You notice the craftsmanship before you reach the front door: Hardie plank board-and-batten siding, a stone foundation and stone-wrapped columns that give this 2021-built home a quietly commanding presence on its 2.42-acre parcel. Set inside the Old Wildlife Club and just 0.2 miles from Lake James, 40 Kingfisher Trace #108 blends mountain materials with modern systems—metal and shingle roofing, underground electric, heat-pump HVAC, and a tankless water heater—so this retreat is built for low-maintenance living.
Step inside to vaulted ceilings and engineered hardwood floors that run through the main gathering spaces. A floor-to-ceiling stone fireplace anchors the great room while the kitchen presents granite counters, a large center island and abundant cabinetry—an ideal hub whether you’re hosting friends after a day on the water or preparing family meals. The primary suite on the main level affords privacy, a walk-in closet, an elevated bathroom layout and convenient main-floor laundry.
Upstairs, a charming loft secured by a sliding barn door offers flexible space for an office, play area or additional sleeping nook; an extra bedroom completes the upper level. The finished lower level was designed for entertaining: another full stone fireplace, a large granite wet bar, two bedrooms joined by a Jack-and-Jill bath, extensive storage and a clever doghouse tucked beneath the stairs.
Outdoor living here is exceptional. Trex decking on the front porch and rear deck, a massive screened-in back deck, full concrete patio and a large firepit area create multiple settings for gatherings, quiet evenings and alfresco meals. Membership to Camp Lake James is included, and the home conveys a deeded boat slip—so launching a boat or taking an evening cruise on Lake James is part of the everyday lifestyle. Whether you’re seeking a year-round residence or a Lake James getaway, this property’s combination of high-quality finishes, thoughtful layout and community amenities delivers a rare package in today’s market.
See the properties helping shape the valuation.
Comparable sales
- 245 SF larger
- Similar lot size
- Same year built
- 849 SF smaller
- 0.5 fewer bathrooms
- 18,295 SF smaller lot
- 4 years older
- 713 SF larger
- 1 additional bathroom
- 18,295 SF smaller lot
- 2 years newer
A 2021 rustic on 2.42 acres.
Building
Site & utilities
Old Wildlife Club
Researched nearby locations
Location
40 Kingfisher Trce #108, Nebo, NC 28761
Old Wildlife Club sits on the shores of Lake James, offering a blend of wooded privacy and lake lifestyle. The community is quiet and well-maintained, with private roads, easy cart or short drives to Camp Lake James and shoreline access. Residents enjoy social programming, on-site amenities—pool, fitness center and courts—and quick access to Lake James State Park for hiking. Local schools are served by McDowell County Schools, and the area attracts both full-time homeowners and vacation buyers seeking outdoor recreation without sacrificing quality construction and community services.
Excellent lake and park access: Camp Lake James amenities and a deeded boat slip are within a short cart ride, with Lake James State Park hiking and water recreation about 3 miles away.
A factual market snapshot around 40 Kingfisher Trce #108.
Nebo and the Lake James corridor are currently favoring buyers, with inventory near six months and an average days-on-market around 115. That environment is giving buyers time to compare options, but homes in established lake communities like Old Wildlife Club remain resilient because of access and community amenities. Median sales in the broader area sit near $438,500, while high-quality, lake-access single-family homes command premium pricing—recent comparable sales in the same community range from roughly $949K to $2.495M depending on size and direct waterfront. For a modern 2021-built home with deeded boat slip and Camp Lake James membership, competitive pricing at $1,195,000 aligns with a midpoint valuation near $1.2M identified by sales-comparison analysis. This is a good time to consider purchasing if you value long-term appreciation tied to Lake James lifestyle amenities; sellers may show flexibility due to longer market exposure, but desirable inventory is still selective. Buyers should factor HOA dues (approx. $6,400 annually) and membership benefits into total cost-of-ownership while leveraging current market conditions to negotiate terms.
Residential
Zoning
Research-indicated uses
- Single Family Residential
Assessment data and recorded transactions.
Assessed value is kept visually separate from the CompCasa market-value estimate.
Sale history
What the research supports — and what is still worth verifying.
Key findings
- Property listed for sale at $1,195,000 as of March 8, 2026
- Initial sale post-construction in 2021 for $680,000
- Located on a 2.42-acre lot with proximity to Lake James
- Membership to Camp Lake James included, offering extensive amenities
- Includes a deeded boat slip for easy lake access
Still worth verifying
Routine buyer due diligence items; these are not known defects.
- Confirm lot dimensions and boundaries
- Verify HOA fees and membership details
- Review community restrictions and covenants
- Professional home inspection
- Confirm deeded boat slip details
What stands out about this property.
Interior Features
- 4 bedrooms, 3.5 bathrooms
- Engineered hardwood floors on main level
- Vaulted ceilings and floor-to-ceiling stone fireplace
- Granite countertops and large center island
- Finished full basement with second stone fireplace
- Granite wet bar in lower level
- Loft with sliding barn door
- Main-floor primary suite with walk-in closet
- Main-floor laundry
- Tankless water heater
Exterior & Lot
- 2.42-acre sloped lot
- Hardie plank board-and-batten siding with stone foundation
- Trex decking on front porch and rear deck
- Massive screened-in back deck
- Full concrete patio and large firepit area
- No garage; spacious driveway with room for multiple vehicles
- Private road frontage on Kingfisher Trace
Location & Neighborhood
- Old Wildlife Club community
- Camp Lake James membership included
- Deeded boat slip for Lake James
- Lake James 0.2 miles; Lake James State Park ~3 miles
- McDowell County schools: Nebo Elementary, East McDowell Middle, McDowell High
- Quiet, wooded residential setting
Walkability & Recreation
- Walkability Rating: 30/100 — Car-Dependent
- Nearby parks and green spaces: Lake James State Park (approx. 3 miles)
- Camp Lake James amenities (0.5 miles): pool, fitness center, dining, tennis/pickleball
- Deeded boat slip for quick lake access
- Running/walking paths and shoreline access near community
- Community recreation facilities and social events
Sources & research confidence.
See where the property research came from and how confidence varies by field.