Property listing for 2670 Kelly Ave, McKinleyville, CA 95519
ActiveSingle Family Home

$819,000

2670 Kelly Ave, McKinleyville, CA 95519

Ocean-View 5BR on Nearly 1-Acre — Fixer with Big Potential

5 Bed · 2,517 Sq Ft

Large lot, sweeping whitewater views, Hammond Trail access — bring your vision.

5

Beds

2,517

Sq Ft

1966

Built

0.92 acres

Lot

No attached garage listed; driveway/surface parking

Garage

About 2670 Kelly Ave

If you’ve been searching for a rare McKinleyville parcel with real whitewater views and room to spread out, 2670 Kelly Ave delivers the setting — and the possibilities. Perched above town on nearly 0.92 acres, this mid-1960s two-level home offers five bedrooms across ~2,517 square feet, with an upper-level main living area that opens onto a huge deck facing the Pacific. The layout gives you flexible living: vaulted ceilings in the main living space, a large kitchen and living room that flow to the deck for entertaining, and a separate downstairs living room with its own entry — a configuration that can accommodate guests, extended family, or a future ADU conversion (buyer to verify).

This is a classic value-add opportunity: the “bones are there” — generous room sizes, classic mid-century proportions, and the most important asset, the view — but cosmetic and systems updating will allow you to capture meaningful equity. The deck and upper living area are the showpieces: wide-sweeping ocean and coast views that create an outdoor room perfect for barbecues, sunset gatherings, or morning coffee while watching surf breaks. The large lot provides privacy and layout options: gardens, garages, or ancillary structures are all possibilities subject to permitting.

Location is a standout. You’re steps from the Hammond Trail for biking and walking, minutes from Clam Beach and other coastal access points, and a short drive to McKinleyville’s shops and services — yet the setting feels private and coastal. With an asking price of $819,000, this home sits in a niche of the local market where lots with views and acreage command premiums. For buyers who value place and potential, this is a canvas that rewards thoughtful investment.

Bring your contractor and your design ideas. Key next steps: verify bath count and mechanical condition, review septic/water utility details, and consult the county on coastal setbacks if you intend structural changes. Showings by appointment with the listing agent — this property moves for buyers who can act on vision.

Home Highlights

Huge ocean-facing deck and vaulted main living areaNearly 1-acre lot — rare scale for McKinleyville propertiesSeparate lower-level entry/living area with ADU potentialDirect access to Hammond Trail and minutes to beachesValue-add opportunity priced to reflect renovation needs

Property Features

Interior Features

  • Approximately 2,517 square feet of living space
  • 5 bedrooms including versatile downstairs living/entry area
  • Vaulted ceilings in main living area
  • Generous kitchen and open living footprint
  • Layout conducive to an ADU or guest suite conversion (buyer to verify)

Exterior & Lot

  • Large deck with ocean and whitewater views
  • ~0.92 acre / 40,075 SF lot offering privacy and expansion potential
  • Surface parking and driveway — no attached garage listed
  • Close proximity to Hammond Trail and coastal beaches
  • Mature plantings and open yard spaces for gardens or outbuildings

Location & Neighborhood

  • Immediate access to Hammond Trail (walking/biking)
  • Minutes to Clam Beach and local coastal recreational areas
  • Short drive to central McKinleyville services and schools
  • Quiet residential setting with coastal community character

Walkability & Recreation

  • Walkability Rating: 45/100
  • Nearby trails, beaches, and coastal parks within minutes
  • Excellent access for outdoor recreation: cycling, surf, beachcombing

Neighborhood & Location

McKinleyville is a coastal community north of Eureka with a small-town, outdoors-oriented character. Neighborhoods range from compact residential streets to larger lots perched for ocean views. Residents enjoy easy access to the Hammond Trail, multiple coastal beaches, and local shops and restaurants clustered near Central Ave. The area attracts families, outdoor enthusiasts, and buyers seeking a quieter coastal lifestyle within reach of regional centers.

Market Insights

McKinleyville and greater Humboldt County have seen steady, moderate appreciation over recent years driven by limited supply, lifestyle demand, and the premium paid for coastal access. Inventory is tighter for view lots and larger parcels, which generally sell faster than typical suburban stock. Median sale prices in the area remain below coastal-city averages, but unique properties like this — large lot + whitewater view — sit above neighborhood medians and attract both local buyers and those seeking a second-home lifestyle. Expect modest competition from owner-occupiers and investors; buyers should be prepared for inspection contingencies and to budget for system and cosmetic upgrades to fully realize value.

Nearby Schools

McKinleyville Elementary (approx.)

Elementary · 1.0 mi

6/10

McKinleyville Middle School (approx.)

Middle · 1.2 mi

6/10

Regional High School (Northern Humboldt/Arcata area — verify)

High · 3.0 mi

5/10

Walkability & Recreation

45
Walkability
85
Recreation

Excellent immediate access to trails and beaches; ideal for biking, hiking and coastal activities.

Investment Highlights

  • Large ~0.92-acre lot—rare in McKinleyville for coastal-view parcels
  • Upper-level living with vaulted ceilings and expansive ocean-facing deck
  • Separate downstairs entry/living area suitable for guests or potential ADU conversion (verify)
  • Immediate proximity to Hammond Trail and minutes to Clam Beach
  • List price aligned with AVM; opportunity to add value through renovation

Key Findings

  • 5 bedrooms and ~2,517 SF on a 40,075 SF lot (0.92 ac).
  • Built in 1966; interior and systems likely require updates.
  • List price $819,000; AVM ~$816,289 and price/sf ≈ $325.
  • Strong location premiums due to ocean views and trail/beach access.
  • Potential permitting considerations because of coastal zone proximity.

Things to Consider

  • Bathroom count not provided in public scraping — verify actual number and layout.
  • Condition is described as fixer; renovation budgets can escalate (mechanical, roof, decks).
  • Septic/water/sewer service details unknown — critical for permitting/ADU conversion.
  • Coastal permitting and setbacks may restrict certain exterior work or expansion.

Opportunity Analysis

Acquire a large-lot ocean-view residence priced to reflect needed renovations; invest modest capital to modernize interiors and decks to capture view premium and resale value in a market that rewards unique coastal properties.

Potential Use Scenarios

  • Buy with an inspection contingency and clear renovation budget (kitchen, baths, deck/rail safety).
  • Obtain feasibility study for ADU/guest suite conversion leveraging the lower-level separate entry.
  • Engage civil/permit consultant early to understand coastal zone/setback limitations.
  • Stage or partially renovate key rooms (kitchen + master bath) to maximize resale value per dollar.

Risk Factors

  • Unknown condition of major systems (roof, foundation, septic).
  • Potentially higher-permit costs and timeline due to coastal regulations.
  • Market sensitivity to economic cycles — Humboldt demand is steady but not hyper-localized.

Buyers should conduct independent due diligence before making any purchase decisions.

AI Valuation Estimate

Low

$760K

Midpoint

$820K

High

$880K

$325/SF estimated price per square foot

65% confidence

Estimate anchored to the current list price ($819,000) and price/sf shown (≈$325). Range accounts for condition (value-add fixer), large lot, and ocean-view premium in McKinleyville. No live comparable sales pulled — adjust after local comps review and inspection.

As of 2026-03-14

This is a computer-generated estimate for informational purposes only and is not an appraisal or professional valuation.

Market & Area Data

Market Trends

Area Median Price$540,000
Avg Days on Market45 days
Inventory3.5 months
1-Year Appreciation+300.0%

Demographics

Population (1 mi)4,500
Median Income (1 mi)$56,000

Stable small coastal community; limited new supply keeps demand steady for larger lots with views.

Nearby Points of Interest

  • Hammond Trail (0.1 mi)
  • Clam Beach / Mad River Beach (2-3 mi)

Short walk to Hammond Trail, minutes to coastal beaches and regional parks; local shopping, restaurants and services in downtown McKinleyville and quick drive to Arcata/Eureka.

School District

DistrictMcKinleyville Union School District / Northern Humboldt Union High School District
ElementaryMcKinleyville Elementary (estimate) — 6/10
MiddleMcKinleyville Middle School — 6/10
HighPacific Union High / Arcata Union High District students attend nearby high schools (estimate) — 5/10

Market data is based on aggregated public records and may not reflect real-time conditions.

Property Details

Building Details

Year Built1966
Constructionwood frame
Stories2
Basementnone
FireplaceNo
Conditionfair

Lot & Site

Lot Size0.92 acres (40,075 SF)
Topographylevel
Parkingdriveway_and_surface
Parking Spaces4
FrontageStreet frontage along Kelly Ave; large usable rear/side yard toward coastal slope

Utilities

Zoning & Land Use

DescriptionLikely residential single-family zoning (R-1 or county equivalent).
JurisdictionHumboldt County

Allowed Uses

Single family dwellingAccessory dwelling unit (subject to county rules and permitting)Home occupation (limited)
Current Useresidential

Tax & Sale History

Tax Assessment

Are You the Listing Agent?

Claim this property page to feature your contact info, photos, and list price.

Claim This Listing — $49

One-time fee. Your info appears on this page across CompCasa.

Request a Showing

Connect with a licensed local agent in this area.

Request a Showing

Are you a buyer's agent?

Claim ZIP 95519 — $49/yr

Property details may be compiled from public records, MLS-derived data, and automated analysis. Agent claim indicates the agent has claimed this profile or confirmed representation of the property; it does not mean the agent has verified all property details.

Request a Showing