CompCasa Property Analysis · single_family

2670 Kelly Ave

Ocean-View 5BR on Nearly 1-Acre — Fixer with Big Potential

Large lot, sweeping whitewater views, Hammond Trail access — bring your vision.

5 beds2,517 sq ftBuilt 19660.92 acres
CompCasa valuation analysis
Estimated market value
$820,000
Low $760,000 · Midpoint $820,000 · High $880,000
Confidence65%Sales comparison approach
CompCasa estimate$820,000Mar 14, 2026
$760,000$820,000 midpoint$880,000
Price / sq ft$325
Median sale price$540,000
Avg days on market45 days
Inventory3.5 months

Estimate anchored to the current list price ($819,000) and price/sf shown (≈$325). Range accounts for condition (value-add fixer), large lot, and ocean-view premium in McKinleyville. No live comparable sales pulled — adjust after local comps review and inspection.

About the property

Ocean-View 5BR on Nearly 1-Acre — Fixer with Big Potential

If you’ve been searching for a rare McKinleyville parcel with real whitewater views and room to spread out, 2670 Kelly Ave delivers the setting — and the possibilities. Perched above town on nearly 0.92 acres, this mid-1960s two-level home offers five bedrooms across ~2,517 square feet, with an upper-level main living area that opens onto a huge deck facing the Pacific. The layout gives you flexible living: vaulted ceilings in the main living space, a large kitchen and living room that flow to the deck for entertaining, and a separate downstairs living room with its own entry — a configuration that can accommodate guests, extended family, or a future ADU conversion (buyer to verify).

This is a classic value-add opportunity: the “bones are there” — generous room sizes, classic mid-century proportions, and the most important asset, the view — but cosmetic and systems updating will allow you to capture meaningful equity. The deck and upper living area are the showpieces: wide-sweeping ocean and coast views that create an outdoor room perfect for barbecues, sunset gatherings, or morning coffee while watching surf breaks. The large lot provides privacy and layout options: gardens, garages, or ancillary structures are all possibilities subject to permitting.

Location is a standout. You’re steps from the Hammond Trail for biking and walking, minutes from Clam Beach and other coastal access points, and a short drive to McKinleyville’s shops and services — yet the setting feels private and coastal. With an asking price of $819,000, this home sits in a niche of the local market where lots with views and acreage command premiums. For buyers who value place and potential, this is a canvas that rewards thoughtful investment.

Bring your contractor and your design ideas. Key next steps: verify bath count and mechanical condition, review septic/water utility details, and consult the county on coastal setbacks if you intend structural changes. Showings by appointment with the listing agent — this property moves for buyers who can act on vision.

Comparable evidence

See the properties helping shape the valuation.

Comparable sales

01Sold price$720,000
Property addressComparable A (approx)
Sold Sep 1, 2025
Research comparison noteCoastal-view home in McKinleyville needing updates; slightly smaller lot. (Estimated — no live MLS pull.)
02Sold price$860,000
Property addressComparable B (approx)
Sold Jun 15, 2025
Research comparison noteLarger home with ready condition and ocean views; premium for turnkey. (Estimated.)
03Sold price$580,000
Property addressComparable C (approx)
Sold Nov 20, 2025
Research comparison noteInland McKinleyville sale without ocean view; used for baseline neighborhood values. (Estimated.)
Comp methodology: No live comparable sales search available — estimates based on area market knowledge and recent trends. Specific sales and values should be verified via MLS.
Property details

A 1966 mid century single family on 0.92 acres.

Building

Year built1966
ConstructionWood Frame

Site & utilities

Lot size0.92 acres
Stories2
ConditionFair
BasementNone
FireplaceNo
Improvement notesHome marketed as a value-add fixer with strong structural layout: upper living with vaulted ceilings and deck facing ocean views, separate downstairs living/entry suitable for guests or possible ADU conversion (buyer to verify). Extensive photos show original/mid-century finishes and areas needing renovation.
Lot area40,075 sq ft
TopographyLevel
FrontageStreet frontage along Kelly Ave; large usable rear/side yard toward coastal slope
ParkingDriveway And Surface
Parking spaces4
Parking notesNo attached garage listed; driveway and surface parking likely. Detached parking/storage structures possible.
AccessPrimary access from Kelly Ave; near local arterial for quick freeway access to US-101.
Location & nearby

McKinleyville / Hammond Trail corridor

Researched nearby locations

Hammond Trail (0.1 mi)
Clam Beach / Mad River Beach (2-3 mi)

Location

2670 Kelly Ave, McKinleyville, CA 95519

View in Google Maps
Editorial neighborhood context

McKinleyville is a coastal community north of Eureka with a small-town, outdoors-oriented character. Neighborhoods range from compact residential streets to larger lots perched for ocean views. Residents enjoy easy access to the Hammond Trail, multiple coastal beaches, and local shops and restaurants clustered near Central Ave. The area attracts families, outdoor enthusiasts, and buyers seeking a quieter coastal lifestyle within reach of regional centers.

Nearby access summary

Excellent immediate access to trails and beaches; ideal for biking, hiking and coastal activities.

ElementaryMcKinleyville Elementary (estimate) — 6/10
Middle schoolMcKinleyville Middle School — 6/10
High schoolPacific Union High / Arcata Union High District students attend nearby high schools (estimate) — 5/10
School districtMcKinleyville Union School District / Northern Humboldt Union High School District
Market context

A factual market snapshot around 2670 Kelly Ave.

Median sale price$540,000
Avg days on market45 days
Inventory3.5 months
1-year appreciation300.0%
5-year appreciation1200.0%
Editorial market perspective

McKinleyville and greater Humboldt County have seen steady, moderate appreciation over recent years driven by limited supply, lifestyle demand, and the premium paid for coastal access. Inventory is tighter for view lots and larger parcels, which generally sell faster than typical suburban stock. Median sale prices in the area remain below coastal-city averages, but unique properties like this — large lot + whitewater view — sit above neighborhood medians and attract both local buyers and those seeking a second-home lifestyle. Expect modest competition from owner-occupiers and investors; buyers should be prepared for inspection contingencies and to budget for system and cosmetic upgrades to fully realize value.

Zoning & land use

Likely residential single-family zoning (R-1 or county equivalent).

Zoning

DescriptionLikely residential single-family zoning (R-1 or county equivalent).
JurisdictionHumboldt County
Current useResidential

Research-indicated uses

  • Single Family Dwelling
  • Accessory Dwelling Unit (Subject To County Rules And Permitting)
  • Home Occupation (Limited)
Verify with the jurisdiction: Zoning, setbacks, and allowed-use summaries are research indicators—not legal advice or a determination that a specific use is permitted.
Research findings & due diligence

What the research supports — and what is still worth verifying.

Key findings

  • 5 bedrooms and ~2,517 SF on a 40,075 SF lot (0.92 ac).
  • Built in 1966; interior and systems likely require updates.
  • List price $819,000; AVM ~$816,289 and price/sf ≈ $325.
  • Strong location premiums due to ocean views and trail/beach access.
  • Potential permitting considerations because of coastal zone proximity.
Highlights & features

What stands out about this property.

Interior Features

  • Approximately 2,517 square feet of living space
  • 5 bedrooms including versatile downstairs living/entry area
  • Vaulted ceilings in main living area
  • Generous kitchen and open living footprint
  • Layout conducive to an ADU or guest suite conversion (buyer to verify)

Exterior & Lot

  • Large deck with ocean and whitewater views
  • ~0.92 acre / 40,075 SF lot offering privacy and expansion potential
  • Surface parking and driveway — no attached garage listed
  • Close proximity to Hammond Trail and coastal beaches
  • Mature plantings and open yard spaces for gardens or outbuildings

Location & Neighborhood

  • Immediate access to Hammond Trail (walking/biking)
  • Minutes to Clam Beach and local coastal recreational areas
  • Short drive to central McKinleyville services and schools
  • Quiet residential setting with coastal community character

Walkability & Recreation

  • Walkability Rating: 45/100
  • Nearby trails, beaches, and coastal parks within minutes
  • Excellent access for outdoor recreation: cycling, surf, beachcombing
Research transparency

Sources & research confidence.

See where the property research came from and how confidence varies by field.

View sources & confidence
1
Redfin pre-scraped JSONView source
Important: This analysis is AI-assisted using pre-scraped listing data and model knowledge. It is not a formal appraisal. Verify all critical facts before making decisions.