$350,000
2421 W Thornton Rd, Show Low, AZ 85901
4-Bed Mountain Retreat — Steps to Fool Hollow Lake
4 Bed · 3 Bath · 2,585 Sq Ft
Spacious single-level living with basement potential and RV parking.
4
Beds
3
Baths
2,585
Sq Ft
2003
Built
0.15 acres
Lot
No garage — driveway & RV parking
Garage
About 2421 W Thornton Rd
Step inside a home designed for gatherings and quiet mountain living. This single-level residence offers 2,585 finished square feet with a layout that separates public and private spaces well: an airy living/dining area with vaulted ceilings flows into a family room, while a generous kitchen provides ample cabinetry and workspace for everyday life and entertaining. The primary suite is set up for comfort — dual-bath access, a jetted soaking tub, and a roomy walk-in closet create a private wing. Three additional bedrooms give flexibility for guests, a home office, or hobby space.
A major asset of this property is the front-level area that provides nearly 800 square feet of basement/workshop space — perfect for finishing into a recreation room, home gym, studio, or dedicated storage and work area while keeping the main living spaces uncluttered. Outdoors, the large covered deck expands your living area and offers a peaceful place to dine or relax beneath towering pines. The lot is practical: room for multiple cars, toys and an RV—rare in many lake-adjacent neighborhoods—and there is no HOA to restrict your plans.
Location is a standout. Walk a few minutes to Fool Hollow Lake for fishing, paddle sports and shoreline trails, or take a short drive to Show Low’s core for restaurants and services. Built in 2003 and well-maintained, this home blends comfortable turn-key living with immediate upside from finishing the workshop/basement area and small cosmetic updates.
If you’re seeking a family-friendly home, a full-time mountain residence, or a vacation property with rental potential close to the lake, this is a compelling offering. Contact the listing agent for showing details and to discuss possible improvements that can unlock additional value.
Home Highlights
Property Features
Interior Features
- Vaulted ceilings in living/dining area
- Separate family room
- Primary suite with jetted soaking tub and dual baths
- Large walk-in closet
- Nearly 800 SF basement/workshop area ready to finish
- Three additional bedrooms or office/flex space
Exterior & Lot
- Covered deck spanning rear living area
- Lot framed by tall pine trees
- Surface parking with space for RV
- No HOA restrictions
- Low-maintenance yard with native landscaping
Location & Neighborhood
- Steps to Fool Hollow Lake and recreation trails
- Short drive to Show Low downtown services
- Quiet West Show Low residential street
- Neighborhood character: mix of year-round homes and seasonal properties
Walkability & Recreation
- Walkability Rating: 40/100
- Fool Hollow Lake nearby for fishing, boating and walking trails
- Nearby parks and regional trails for hiking and biking
Neighborhood & Location
West Show Low around Thornton Road is a mixed residential area favored by buyers who want quick access to Fool Hollow Lake and the White Mountains’ recreational network. The neighborhood mixes year-round families, retirees and second-home owners; streets are lined with pines and yards are generally low-maintenance. Downtown Show Low and key services are within a short drive, making the area convenient while still feeling like a mountain retreat.
Market Insights
Show Low’s housing market sits between seasonal recreation demand and year-round local buyers. Median sales in the area have been modestly rising over recent years; pricing is generally lower than Arizona’s urban markets, creating relative affordability for buyers seeking mountain and lake access. Inventory in 2026 is moderate, giving buyers options but still rewarding well-priced, well-presented homes that emphasize outdoor access and parking flexibility. With 84 days on market, this property may attract buyers seeking negotiating room; finish the basement and update bathrooms/kitchen modestly to push resale value toward the top of the local range.
Nearby Schools
Whipple Elementary School
Elementary · 1.0 mi
Show Low Middle School
Middle · 1.8 mi
Show Low High School
High · 2.0 mi
Walkability & Recreation
Exceptional immediate access to Fool Hollow Lake for boating, fishing and shoreline trails; broader access to White Mountains hiking and winter recreation within a short drive.
Investment Highlights
- Short walk to Fool Hollow Lake — high recreational appeal
- Large living area (2,585 SF) with separate family room and vaulted ceilings
- Nearly 800 SF basement/workshop space with finish potential
- No HOA and space for RV parking — flexibility for owners
- Well-priced relative to local median; attractive for buyers seeking mountain/lake access
Key Findings
- 4 beds / 3 baths, 2,585 SF, built 2003 — listed at $350,000
- Lot size ~6,443 SF (~0.15 acres) with mature pines and surface parking
- Basement/unfinished area (~800 SF) presents conversion upside
- Property is within easy walking distance to Fool Hollow Lake
- Days on market: 84 — indicates price sensitivity or buyer-selective market
Things to Consider
- Utility specifics (sewer/water/gas) are not specified and should be verified
- No attached garage — buyers seeking covered vehicle storage will need to add
- Market liquidity in small mountain towns can be slower; 84 DOM signals possible negotiation room
Opportunity Analysis
Buyers seeking a family home or lake-adjacent retreat can capture value by securing a well-sized property with upside through basement finish and modest updating. The location near Fool Hollow Lake supports demand from both permanent residents and short-term renters.
Potential Use Scenarios
- For owner-occupiers: negotiate price given DOM and invest $20k–$50k to finish basement and modernize primary bath/kitchen to lift value toward the high estimate.
- For investors: consider short-term rental or vacation rental seasonally; budget for marketing to lake visitors.
- Confirm utilities and permitting environment before planning structural changes.
Risk Factors
- Local demand is seasonal and tied to recreation; winter months may see slower interest.
- Unknowns around utilities and HVAC may require unplanned expenditures.
- No garage reduces appeal to buyers who expect enclosed vehicle storage in colder months.
Buyers should conduct independent due diligence before making any purchase decisions.
AI Valuation Estimate
Low
$325K
Midpoint
$350K
High
$375K
$135/SF estimated price per square foot
Estimate anchored to list price of $350,000 and adjusted for size (2,585 SF), year (2003), finished living area plus ~800 SF basement potential, proximity to Fool Hollow Lake, and regional market norms for Show Low. No live comparable sales pulled; estimates reflect model knowledge of local pricing.
As of 2026-03-13
This is a computer-generated estimate for informational purposes only and is not an appraisal or professional valuation.
Market & Area Data
Market Trends
Demographics
Show Low is a small mountain community with steady seasonal visitation; population growth is slow but steady, trending toward retirees, second-home buyers and year-round locals.
Nearby Points of Interest
- Fool Hollow Lake (0.1 mi)
- Show Low City Park (1.5 mi)
Property is a short walk to Fool Hollow Lake and its trails, with easy access to Show Low's downtown retail and services within a few minutes' drive. Area offers outdoor recreation — fishing, boating, hiking — plus local dining and grocery options a short drive away.
School District
Market data is based on aggregated public records and may not reflect real-time conditions.
Property Details
Building Details
Lot & Site
Utilities
Zoning & Land Use
Allowed Uses
Tax & Sale History
Tax Assessment
Are You the Listing Agent?
Claim this property page to feature your contact info, photos, and list price.
Claim This Listing — $49One-time fee. Your info appears on this page across CompCasa.
Request a Showing
Connect with a licensed local agent in this area.
Request a ShowingAre you a buyer's agent?
Claim ZIP 85901 — $49/yrProperty details may be compiled from public records, MLS-derived data, and automated analysis. Agent claim indicates the agent has claimed this profile or confirmed representation of the property; it does not mean the agent has verified all property details.