Property listing for 204 Old Mill Rd, Castle Hayne, NC, 28429
For SaleSingle Family Home

$325,000

204 Old Mill Rd, Castle Hayne, NC, 28429

Car-Lift Equipped Workshop and Spacious Backyard Opportunity

3 Bed · 2 Bath · 1,216 Sq Ft

3BR/2BA Castle Hayne home with a wired detached shop — ideal for hobbyists

3

Beds

2

Baths

1,216

Sq Ft

1980

Built

Detached 2-car garage/shop (car lift wired for 7,000 lb)

Garage

About 204 Old Mill Rd

The first thing that catches your eye at 204 Old Mill Rd is the workshop: a detached, two-car garage wired and outfitted for heavy work, including a car lift rated for 7,000 lb vehicles. That singular feature makes this property unusually well suited to mechanics, makers, and anyone who wants serious garage space without giving up a manageable single-story home.

Inside, the 1,216-square-foot floor plan is practical and straightforward. The living spaces flow from a central living area to three bedrooms and two full baths — a layout that feels comfortable and well-proportioned for a small family or a downsizer who values a tidy footprint. The seller has invested in systems buyers appreciate: all-new windows, a new water heater, a new HVAC installed in 2022, and a roof replaced in 2018. Carpet has been refreshed in living areas and bedrooms, giving the interior a neutral, move-in-friendly canvas while the home awaits cosmetic finishing touches.

The kitchen and adjacent rooms offer functional everyday use; thoughtful updates to mechanicals and the window package reduce near-term maintenance concerns and make budgeting for future refreshes easier. Because the home sits on a generous backyard, there’s room to create a garden, build a patio, or expand outdoor storage—an opportunity for anyone looking to add value through landscaping or exterior improvements.

Practicality defines this property: modern HVAC, a recent roof, and durable new windows paired with a specialty outbuilding that’s ready for projects. Whether you’re an owner-operator looking for on-site workshop access, a homeowner seeking a comfortable single-level residence with room to personalize, or an investor focusing on resilient systems, this Castle Hayne property is a rare combination of everyday livability and enthusiast-grade workspace.

Home Highlights

Detached garage/shop wired for 7,000 lb car liftNew HVAC (2022) and new windowsRoof replaced in 2018New water heater1,216 sq ft single-story layoutLarge backyard with development potential

Property Features

Interior Features

  • 3 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms
  • 1,216 finished square feet
  • New windows throughout
  • New water heater
  • New HVAC installed in 2022
  • Newer carpeting in living areas and bedrooms

Exterior & Lot

  • Detached 2-car garage/shop wired for a 7,000 lb car lift
  • Large backyard with room for landscaping or expansion
  • Recent roof replacement (2018)
  • Low-maintenance exterior framing and yard

Location & Neighborhood

  • Located in Castle Hayne, NC
  • Residential setting with local services and conveniences nearby
  • Easy access to regional roads (confirm current commuting routes with agent)
  • Quiet lot suitable for outdoor projects and private yard use

Walkability & Recreation

  • Walkability Rating: 28/100 — Car-Dependent
  • Nearby parks and green spaces for weekend activity
  • Local opportunities for boating and coastal recreation within the broader region
  • Room for private outdoor amenities—gardens, patio, or play space

Neighborhood & Location

Castle Hayne offers a quieter, small-community residential atmosphere with local services and a slower pace compared with larger nearby coastal cities. The neighborhood attracts buyers who prioritize outdoor space and practical outbuildings: yards are often roomy, and properties with detached garages or workshops are common draws. Residents typically rely on short drives for grocery shopping, dining, and regional recreation, while appreciating the privacy and room to pursue hobbies at home. For those who value a balance of residential calm and access to coastal amenities, Castle Hayne provides a compelling setting.

Market Insights

This listing is competitively positioned at the broker list price of $325,000, which matches the valuation midpoint in the available estimate data ($325,000) and a calculated price-per-square-foot of roughly $267. The valuation confidence is moderate (0.65), indicating the estimate is helpful but buyers should confirm comps and current active inventory with a local agent. Without precise days-on-market and active inventory figures in the immediate dataset, treat this as a targeted value play: homes with dedicated workshop spaces and updated major systems (HVAC 2022, roof 2018, new windows) typically attract both owner-occupant buyers seeking durability and investors looking for lower near-term capital needs. For buyers, the present opportunity is to leverage the solid mechanicals while customizing finishes; for sellers, emphasizing the specialized garage and recent system upgrades will differentiate the home in marketing. Always consult up-to-date local MLS metrics for Castle Hayne and nearby Wilmington-area corridors to evaluate current absorption rates, median price movement, and competitive days-on-market prior to offer strategy.

Walkability & Recreation

28
Walkability
68
Recreation

Good access to regional outdoor recreation — local parks and greenways, plus broader coastal and water-based activities in the surrounding region; ample private yard space for gardens, patios, and hobby use.

AI Valuation Estimate

Low

$312K

Midpoint

$325K

High

$338K

$267/SF estimated price per square foot

65% confidence

Derived from Redfin listing LD+JSON

This is a computer-generated estimate for informational purposes only and is not an appraisal or professional valuation.

Market & Area Data

Nearby Points of Interest

  • Nearby parks and green spaces for weekend activity

Castle Hayne offers a quieter, small-community residential atmosphere with local services and a slower pace compared with larger nearby coastal cities. The neighborhood attracts buyers who prioritize outdoor space and practical outbuildings: yards are often roomy, and properties with detached garages or workshops are common draws. Residents typically rely on short drives for grocery shopping, dining, and regional recreation, while appreciating the privacy and room to pursue hobbies at home. For those who value a balance of residential calm and access to coastal amenities, Castle Hayne provides a compelling setting.

Market data is based on aggregated public records and may not reflect real-time conditions.

Find a Local Agent

Looking to buy or sell? Connect with a licensed local agent who knows this area.

Request a Showing

Your inquiry will be connected with a licensed local real estate professional through our brokerage partner.

Are You a Local Agent?

No agency is currently featured for this market. Join the CompCasa Local Partner Program to get your brokerage placed on property pages like this one.

Learn About the Partner Program

CompCasa is a marketing and technology platform. All brokerage services are provided by licensed partners.