Homes/Colorado/Berthoud/County Road 1
CompCasa Property Analysis · single_family

County Road 1

Two Finished Homes on 4 Acres—Private Berthoud Compound

Turnkey dual-home estate with outbuildings and no HOA.

5,448 sq ftBuilt 18904 acres4-car garage on primary parcel plus lean-tos; additional yard/outbuilding storage; covered hay shed (1277 SF)
CompCasa valuation analysis
Estimated market value
$1,950,000
Low $1,800,000 · Midpoint $1,950,000 · High $2,100,000
Confidence65%Sales comparison approach
Last recorded sale$1,950,000Feb 23, 2026
CompCasa estimate$1,950,000Mar 12, 2026
Estimate vs. last recorded sale+$0 / +0.0%
$1,800,000$1,950,000 midpoint$2,100,000
Price / sq ft$618
Median sale price$650,000
Avg days on market35 days
Inventory2.5 months

Estimate anchored to current MLS list price of $1,950,000; range +/- ~10-15% reflects dual-dwelling configuration, land value for 4 acres near Berthoud, and comparable Northern Colorado rural sales trends. No live comp pull was available; values inferred from listing history and regional market knowledge.

About the property

Two Finished Homes on 4 Acres—Private Berthoud Compound

This extraordinary, dual-deeded property delivers two fully finished homes on a rare 4-acre parcel just minutes from downtown Berthoud. Offered as a package, the main residence (19858 County Road 1) honors its 1890 provenance while offering contemporary luxury across ~1,931 SF of main-level living and a sizable cellar. Thoughtful finishes include a dedicated office, beverage bar, and an outdoor kitchen that extends entertaining to beautifully landscaped grounds. The secondary home (19810 County Road 1) — circa 1940 — provides ~1,225 SF main-level living (plus cellar), a private-entry primary suite and classic, upgraded interiors that keep both residences comfortable and turnkey.

Outside, the property is set up for small-acreage living: a 1,277 SF open hay shed with two silos, multiple lean-to storage areas, sprinklered landscaping and expansive lawn sections. Parking and equipment storage are easy with a generous 4-car garage on-site and hard-surfaced drive areas. Utilities include public water, onsite septic systems, electricity availability and propane. With no HOA or metro district, this offering gives buyers flexibility to use the site as a family compound, rental-income property, hobby farm or creative estate.

The homes are presented in excellent condition — high-quality finishes reduce immediate maintenance needs and accelerate potential rental or owner-occupancy timelines. Showings are by one-day notice; listing agent will be present for all visits. Buyers should verify septic capacity and parcel details but will find a rare, move-in-ready combination of historic character and modern comfort in a quiet rural setting just a short drive to Loveland, Longmont and Fort Collins.

Property details

A 1890 single family on 4 acres.

Building

Year built1890
ConstructionWood Frame/Typical Colorado Residential With Outbuildings

Site & utilities

Lot size4 acres
Garage4-car garage on primary parcel plus lean-tos; additional yard/outbuilding storage; covered hay shed (1277 SF)
Stories1
ConditionExcellent
BasementPartial/Finished Cellars
FireplaceNo
Improvement notesDual-deeded package including TWO separate finished residences: Main house (19858 County Rd #1) — built 1890, approx. 1,931 SF main level + 1,934 SF cellar; 2 BR / 3 BA, dedicated office, beverage bar, outdoor kitchen, lush landscaping. Secondary home (19810 County Rd 1) — built circa 1940, approx. 1,225 SF main level + 358 SF cellar; 3 BR / 2 BA, primary suite with private entrance. Property includes a 1,277 SF open hay shed with 2 silos and multiple lean-to storage areas. Meticulous finishes reported throughout both homes.
Lot area174,240 sq ft
TopographyLevel
FrontageCountry road frontage on County Road 1; private drive
ParkingDetached Garage And Outbuildings
Parking spaces8
Parking notesPrimary residence includes a 4-car garage and two lean-to storage areas; additional yard parking and an open hay shed (approx 1,277 SF). Property currently shows asphalt and concrete drive surfaces.
AccessDirect access from County Road 1; rural county road — year-round access typical for area
WaterPublic Water Available
SewerSeptic Tank (Septic Systems Present)
ElectricElectricity Available
GasPropane
Location & nearby

Rural Berthoud / County Road 1 corridor

Researched nearby locations

Downtown Berthoud (approx. 3-5 miles)
Loveland (approx. 12-15 miles)

Location

19858 County Road 1, Berthoud, CO 80513

View in Google Maps
Editorial neighborhood context

This property sits along County Road 1 in the rural outskirts of Berthoud — a pocket of small-acreage homes, hobby farms and ranch-adjacent parcels. The neighborhood provides privacy and open-sky views while remaining only a few minutes from Berthoud’s compact downtown. Residents value the rural character, local schools, and rapid access to larger regional centers (Loveland, Longmont, Fort Collins) for shopping, healthcare and employment.

Nearby access summary

Ample outdoor access — open space, trails and equestrian-friendly parcels nearby make this attractive for buyers seeking recreation, riding or gardening opportunities.

ElementaryBerthoud Elementary School (approx. 3-5 miles) — rating estimate 7/10
Middle schoolBerthoud Middle School (approx. 3-5 miles) — rating estimate 7/10
High schoolBerthoud High School (approx. 3-6 miles) — rating estimate 6/10
School districtLikely Thompson School District R2-J / or local district overlap — confirm with county records
Market context

A factual market snapshot around County Road 1.

Median sale price$650,000
Avg days on market35 days
Inventory2.5 months
1-year appreciation800.0%
5-year appreciation3000.0%
Editorial market perspective

Northern Colorado continues to post stronger-than-average demand for rural and small-acreage properties as buyers seek space within commutable distance of Fort Collins, Loveland and the Boulder/Longmont employment corridors. Inventory for unique dual-dwelling parcels is particularly limited; when properly priced these properties attract a mix of lifestyle buyers and investors. Median single-family prices in the broader Fort Collins–Loveland area have shown mid-single-digit to high-single-digit annual appreciation recently, and well-upgraded turnkey rural compounds tend to trade at a premium to raw land because of immediate usability and rental potential. Given this, the current asking price of $1.95M positions the property competitively for buyers seeking a multi-residence solution without the time and permitting cost of building new structures.

Zoning & land use

Rural residential / agricultural county zoning is likely; allows single-family residences, accessory structures, limited agricultural uses and equestrian activities (verify exact code with county).

Zoning

DescriptionRural residential / agricultural county zoning is likely; allows single-family residences, accessory structures, limited agricultural uses and equestrian activities (verify exact code with county).
JurisdictionLarimer County (rural residential/agricultural likely)
Current useResidential
SetbacksSetbacks and building envelopes subject to Larimer County regulations; hedgerows and irrigation ditches may impose additional constraints.

Research-indicated uses

  • Primary Residential Use
  • Accessory Dwellings / Guest Houses (Subject To County Rules)
  • Small Scale Agricultural And Equestrian Uses
  • Outbuildings And Storage Related To Residential/Ag Use
Verify with the jurisdiction: Zoning, setbacks, and allowed-use summaries are research indicators—not legal advice or a determination that a specific use is permitted.
Tax & sale history

Assessment data and recorded transactions.

Assessed value is kept visually separate from the CompCasa market-value estimate.

Sale history

1998-05-22$800,000
2024-06-03$2,500,000
2024-07-22$1,500,000
2025-03-06$2,100,000
2026-02-23$1,950,000
Research findings & due diligence

What the research supports — and what is still worth verifying.

Key findings

  • Listing price: **$1,950,000** (current active MLS listing).
  • Dual properties: Primary house (1890) ~1,931 SF main; Secondary house (c.1940) ~1,225 SF main.
  • Total finished/common building area (main floors) ~3,156 SF; including cellars/outbuildings total building footprint reported ~5,448 SF.
  • 4 acres of land (approx. 174,240 SF) — professionally landscaped with irrigation and sprinklers mentioned.
  • Utilities: public water, septic systems, electricity available, propane on-site.
Highlights & features

What stands out about this property.

Interior Features

  • Main house: 2 BR / 3 BA, dedicated office, beverage bar
  • Secondary house: 3 BR / 2 BA, private-entry primary suite
  • Wood flooring in main living areas
  • Appliances: cooktop, oven, microwave, dishwasher, refrigerator, washer/dryer, bar fridge
  • Finished cellars provide substantial additional usable space

Exterior & Lot

  • 4.0 irrigated acres with meticulous landscaping and sprinklers
  • 1,277 SF open hay shed with two silos
  • 4-car garage + lean-to storage areas; asphalt/concrete drive surfaces
  • Outdoor kitchen and multiple patio/entertaining areas
  • Fenced areas and infrastructure supportive of hobby-farm/equestrian use

Location & Neighborhood

  • Rural Berthoud setting — private, low-traffic county road
  • Minutes from downtown Berthoud amenities, services and schools
  • Approx. 12–20 miles to regional employment and services in Loveland, Longmont and Fort Collins
  • No HOA or metro district

Walkability & Recreation

  • Walkability Rating: 28/100
  • Close to local open space, regional trails and recreational riding areas
  • Quick vehicle access to parks and recreation in Berthoud and Loveland
Research transparency

Sources & research confidence.

See where the property research came from and how confidence varies by field.

View sources & confidence
1
Redfin scraped listing JSONView source
2
IRES MLS entries (as provided in price history)
Important: This analysis is AI-assisted using pre-scraped listing data and model knowledge. It is not a formal appraisal. Verify all critical facts before making decisions.