Homes/Florida/St. Augustine/1255 Ponce Island Dr #C-734
CompCasa Property Analysis · Condominium

1255 Ponce Island Dr #C-734

Quiet Waterfront Condo with Kayak Launch & Lofted Bedroom

Low-maintenance 1BR/2BA condo minutes from Historic St. Augustine

CompCasa valuation analysis
Estimated market value
$129,000
Low $123,840 · Midpoint $129,000 · High $134,160
Confidence65%Sales comparison approach
CompCasa estimate$129,000Current analysis
$123,840$129,000 midpoint$134,160
Price / sq ft$221

Derived from Redfin listing LD+JSON

About the property

Quiet Waterfront Condo with Kayak Launch & Lofted Bedroom

What sets this Tennis Village at the Ponce condominium apart is its direct access to the Tolomato River—rare in a tucked-away community this close to downtown St. Augustine. Perched on the second floor, Unit C-734 delivers a compact, smartly arranged living experience with 585 square feet laid out across two levels. The living area soars with vaulted ceilings, creating an immediate sense of space. Off the living room, a balcony overlooks the well-kept tennis courts and the mature oaks that define the community.

Downstairs is an open eating area and kitchen adjacent to a full bath—an efficient setup for everyday living and for hosting friends before a paddle on the river. Upstairs, a loft-style bedroom looks down into the living room and includes its own full bathroom, offering separation and privacy while preserving the condo's airy character. The interior’s footprint is deceptively generous thanks to thoughtful sightlines and the two-story living volume.

Outside the unit, Tennis Village’s amenities amplify the coastal lifestyle: a community pool for easy cooling-off, tennis courts, and expanses of green lawn shaded by mature trees. HOA dues are a practical advantage here—covering water, sewer, cable, pest control, and garbage—so maintenance is minimal and the property functions well as a primary residence, a seasonal retreat, or a lock-and-leave option.

Location is part of the appeal. Historic St. Augustine’s restaurants, boutiques, and cultural attractions are minutes away, and local beaches and waterfront recreation are easily accessible for weekend escapes. For buyers who value waterfront access without the upkeep of a single-family home, this condo offers a genuine slice of coastal living with the convenience of downtown nearby. Given the compact, thoughtfully designed interior and the community’s outdoor amenities, this unit is an attractive, affordable entry into St. Augustine’s waterfront market.

Location & nearby

St. Augustine, FL

Researched nearby locations

Direct kayak launch access to the Tolomato River
Short drive to local beaches
Close to dining and shopping
On-site kayak launch to Tolomato River
Nearby beaches and waterfront recreation within a short drive

Location

1255 Ponce Island Dr #C-734, St. Augustine, FL, 32095

View in Google Maps
Editorial neighborhood context

Tennis Village at the Ponce sits quietly along the Tolomato River corridor, offering a blend of leafy communal green space and easy access to waterfront recreation. The neighborhood’s character is defined by mature trees, low-rise condo clusters, and active outdoor amenities like tennis courts and a communal pool. Historic downtown St. Augustine is just minutes away, offering a rich menu of restaurants, galleries, and cultural landmarks, while local beaches and marine access provide year-round outdoor options. The community is ideal for buyers seeking a relaxed coastal rhythm with the convenience of nearby town services.

Nearby access summary

Strong waterfront recreation with on-site kayak access to the Tolomato River, a community pool and tennis courts, plus quick drives to St. Augustine beaches and local waterfront parks.

Market context

A factual market snapshot around 1255 Ponce Island Dr #C-734.

Editorial market perspective

This listing is competitively positioned at the valuation midpoint ($129,000) derived from local comparables and a $221 price-per-square-foot metric. In St. Augustine, affordable waterfront condos—especially those with direct water access—tend to draw consistent buyer interest because supply in that niche is limited. Condominiums in the lower price bands provide accessibility for first-time buyers and seasonal owners, and they often transact more quickly than larger single-family homes when priced right. The inclusion of utilities in HOA dues is a selling point that broadens the buyer pool. While macro trends fluctuate, a well-priced, low-maintenance riverside unit like this typically attracts attention from buyers seeking lifestyle value rather than raw square footage. For buyers, act with preparedness (pre-approval or proof of funds) to move decisively. For sellers, presenting the unit cleanly and highlighting the turnkey advantages—river access, covered utilities, community amenities—supports a smooth marketing process and helps realize fair market interest.

Highlights & features

What stands out about this property.

Interior Features

  • 1 bedroom loft overlooking living room
  • 2 full bathrooms
  • Vaulted ceilings in living area
  • Eat-in kitchen
  • Open-plan lower level
  • Second-floor unit layout

Exterior & Lot

  • Direct kayak launch access to the Tolomato River
  • Balcony overlooking tennis courts
  • Community pool
  • Tennis courts
  • Open green spaces with mature trees
  • Low-maintenance condo living

Location & Neighborhood

  • Minutes from Historic St. Augustine
  • Short drive to local beaches
  • Close to dining and shopping
  • Quiet, tucked-away community
  • Ponce Island/Tennis Village setting

Walkability & Recreation

  • Walkability Rating: 62/100 — Some errands on foot
  • On-site kayak launch to Tolomato River
  • Community pool and tennis courts
  • Nearby beaches and waterfront recreation within a short drive
  • Neighborhood green spaces and shaded lawns