Homes/North Carolina/Nebo/1195 Old Wildlife Club Dr #89
CompCasa Property Analysis · single_family

1195 Old Wildlife Club Dr #89

Panoramic Lake James & Blue Ridge Views — 2.07 Acres + Garagemahal

Live now in a unique two-bay Garagemahal with boatslip and future-build potential

1 beds2 baths921 sq ftBuilt 20172.071 acresDetached two-bay 'Garagemahal' with one extra-long bay (boat-capable) and upper-level living space
CompCasa valuation analysis
Estimated market value
$1,175,000
Low $1,050,000 · Midpoint $1,175,000 · High $1,300,000
Confidence65%Sales comparison approach
CompCasa estimate$1,175,000Mar 12, 2026
$1,050,000$1,175,000 midpoint$1,300,000
Price / sq ft$1247.95
Median sale price$420,000
Avg days on market35 days
Inventory3.5 months

Estimate anchored to list price of $1,150,000 and AVM (~$1,142,600). Range reflects premium lake/mountain long-range views, included boat slip, detached two-bay garage with living area, and 2+ acre buildable parcel; limited by small existing living square footage (921 SF). No live comps searched — values based on regional lakefront premiums and training data.

About the property

Panoramic Lake James & Blue Ridge Views — 2.07 Acres + Garagemahal

1195 Old Wildlife Club Drive Unit #89 is a rare Lake James opportunity: a thoughtfully built two-bay "Garagemahal" perched on approximately 2.07 acres with expansive long-range water views and Blue Ridge mountain vistas. The living quarters above the garage were designed to showcase the panorama — vaulted ceilings and a wall of windows create a living room that frames the lake like a landscape painting. The open-plan kitchen includes built-in cabinetry and granite counters that make the compact footprint efficient for everyday use and entertaining.

The Garagemahal is the star of the property: one bay is extra-long to accommodate a boat, lake toys, or a generous workshop, and the upper-level living space provides immediate, comfortable accommodation while you plan or build a larger lakeside residence. Outdoor living is prominent here — a broad Trex deck spans the building's main level for unobstructed vistas, and a covered patio and firepit area below provide sheltered relaxation spots that look out across Lake James. A short UTV ride gives access to an easy-to-reach, year-round boatslip included with the property, plus membership access to Camp Lake James amenities (pool, fitness center, tennis/pickleball courts, dining, marina and social events).

Practical details matter: the property was built in 2017 with low-maintenance Hardy siding and stone foundation, includes generous storage and an upstairs washer/dryer, and sits on a sloping parcel that offers privacy and an easy future build site. The living space today is ideal as a primary weekend retreat, full-time small-footprint residence, or premium short-term rental; long-term owners will appreciate the ability to enlarge the footprint or construct a custom dream home to fully capitalize on the views and acreage.

This offering combines immediate usability with development optionality in one of the most sought-after view corridors on Lake James. Early showings are available — buyer advisories include confirming septic/well capacity and title verification of the boatslip and Camp Lake James access prior to closing.

Comparable evidence

See the properties helping shape the valuation.

Comparable sales

01Sold price$1,250,000
Property addressComparable Lake James view property (approx.)
2 bed2 bath1.2 mi
Sold Aug 1, 2025
Subject difference
  • 1 additional bedroom
Research comparison noteLake-view property with dock and finished living area larger than subject; used illustratively — no live MLS pull.
02Sold price$980,000
Property addressLake James waterfront cottage (approx.)
2 bed2 bath3 mi
Sold Oct 15, 2024
Subject difference
  • 1 additional bedroom
Research comparison noteSmaller lot and lower view corridor; demonstrates pricing spread in the area.
Comp methodology: No live comparable sales search available — estimates and comps are illustrative based on regional lakefront market knowledge and should be validated with MLS reports and county records.
Property details

A 2017 cabin|detached garage living on 2.07 acres.

Building

Year built2017
ConstructionWood Frame With Hardy Siding And Stone Foundation

Site & utilities

Lot size2.071 acres
GarageDetached two-bay 'Garagemahal' with one extra-long bay (boat-capable) and upper-level living space
Stories2
ConditionGood
BasementNone
FireplaceNo
Improvement notesPrimary living area above detached garage; vaulted ceilings and large view windows; granite countertops; low-maintenance exterior.
Lot area90,169 sq ft
TopographySloping
FrontageSet above Lake James with long-range water and mountain views; driveway access via Old Wildlife Club Drive
ParkingDetached Garage And Driveway
Parking spaces6
Parking notesLarge detached two-bay garage ('Garagemahal') with one extra-long bay suitable for boat storage; additional driveway parking for multiple vehicles/trailers.
AccessStandard residential access from Old Wildlife Club Drive; UTV path to community boat slip included.
WaterLikely Public Or Community Well (Verify)
SewerLikely Septic (Verify)
ElectricConnected (Verify Provider)
GasLikely Propane Or Electric (Verify)
Location & nearby

Old Wildlife Club / Lake James area

Researched nearby locations

Camp Lake James (amenities & marina) (0.5-1.5 mi)
Lake James State Park (4-8 mi)

Location

1195 Old Wildlife Club Dr #89, Nebo, NC 28761

View in Google Maps
Editorial neighborhood context

Old Wildlife Club at Lake James is a low-density lakeside community favored by second-home buyers, boaters, and outdoor enthusiasts. Properties range from modest cottages to custom estates on wooded parcels, many with deeded access to shared amenities at Camp Lake James. The area offers a blend of privacy, recreational infrastructure, and proximity to small-town services in Marion plus regional centers like Morganton and Hickory.

Nearby access summary

Excellent lake and mountain recreation nearby — boating, fishing, trails, paddle sports, and community courts and pool at Camp Lake James provide varied outdoor options year-round.

ElementaryNebo Elementary School (McDowell County) — rating approx. 6/10
Middle schoolHarmon/McDowell Middle (McDowell County) — rating approx. 6/10
High schoolMcDowell High School — rating approx. 5/10
School districtMcDowell County Schools
Market context

A factual market snapshot around 1195 Old Wildlife Club Dr #89.

Median sale price$420,000
Avg days on market35 days
Inventory3.5 months
1-year appreciation450.0%
5-year appreciation1800.0%
Editorial market perspective

Lake James sits within a niche market where true long-range water and mountain views are scarce and command a premium relative to inland McDowell County housing. Typical median sales in the broader area are substantially lower than this listing, but waterfront or superior-view parcels at Lake James routinely trade at higher multiples due to limited supply and strong demand from second-home buyers and retirees. Inventory for premium lake properties is often tight and seasonal — sellers who price to reflect the view/amenity package frequently see competitive interest in the spring and early summer. Given the property's included boatslip, Camp Lake James access, and buildable acreage, it represents both a lifestyle purchase and an investment in scarce waterfront-adjacent real estate.

Zoning & land use

Residential/lakeside low-density zoning; lot size supports single-family dwelling and accessory structures—verify with county zoning office for building envelope and setbacks.

Zoning

DescriptionResidential/lakeside low-density zoning; lot size supports single-family dwelling and accessory structures—verify with county zoning office for building envelope and setbacks.
JurisdictionMcDowell County
Current useResidential
SetbacksTypical county setbacks apply; steep slopes or setback from lake/shoreline may affect build area—confirm with permitting.

Research-indicated uses

  • Single Family Residence
  • Accessory Buildings (Garage/Workshop)
  • Recreational Accessory Uses Subject To Local Rules
Verify with the jurisdiction: Zoning, setbacks, and allowed-use summaries are research indicators—not legal advice or a determination that a specific use is permitted.
Research findings & due diligence

What the research supports — and what is still worth verifying.

Key findings

  • List price: $1,150,000; AVM: ~$1,142,600.
  • Living area: 921 SF; 1 bed / 2 baths; built in 2017.
  • Lot size: ~90,169 SF (approx. 2.07 acres).
  • Detached 'Garagemahal' accommodates boat and workshop; includes upper-level living with vaulted views.
  • Community amenities (Camp Lake James) increase appeal and rental potential.
Highlights & features

What stands out about this property.

Interior Features

  • Vaulted living room with expansive view wall
  • Efficient open kitchen with granite countertops
  • Primary suite with stand-alone soaking tub
  • Upper-level laundry and ample storage
  • 1 bedroom / 2 bathrooms, 921 SF total living area

Exterior & Lot

  • Approximately 2.07-acre lot (90,169 SF)
  • Large Trex deck spanning main level
  • Covered patio and lakeside firepit
  • Detached two-bay Garagemahal with extra-long bay
  • Low-maintenance hardy siding and stone foundation

Location & Neighborhood

  • Private setting within Old Wildlife Club at Lake James
  • Deeded access to Camp Lake James (pool, marina, fitness, courts)
  • Short UTV ride to a year-round boatslip included
  • 15–25 minute drive to Marion for services; regional access to Morganton/Hickory

Walkability & Recreation

  • Walkability Rating: 18/100
  • Direct access to lake recreation, boat slip, and community courts
  • Nearby Lake James State Park trails and fishing opportunities
Research transparency

Sources & research confidence.

See where the property research came from and how confidence varies by field.

View sources & confidence
1
https://www.redfin.com/NC/Nebo/1195-Old-Wildlife-Club-Dr-28761/unit-89/home/200798799View source
Important: This analysis is AI-assisted using pre-scraped listing data and model knowledge. It is not a formal appraisal. Verify all critical facts before making decisions.