Homes/Ohio/Cleveland/10418 Sandusky Avenue
CompCasa Property Analysis · single_family

10418 Sandusky Avenue

Tenant-Occupied 3BR Colonial with Detached 2-Car Garage

1924 Union-Miles Park home with restoration upside and rental income

3 beds1 baths1,258 sq ftBuilt 19240.101 acresdetached
CompCasa valuation analysis
Estimated market value
$75,000
Low $70,000 · Midpoint $75,000 · High $80,000
Confidence75%Sales comparison approach
Last recorded sale$20,000Feb 24, 2025
Assessed value$9,5202025 assessment
CompCasa estimate$75,000Oct 2, 2026
Estimate vs. last recorded sale+$55,000 / +275.0%
$70,000$75,000 midpoint$80,000
Price / sq ft$59.6
Median sale price$75,000
Avg days on market45 days
Inventory3.5 months

Sales comparison approach using 3 comparable sales within 0.5 miles sold in last 12 months. Adjusted for condition, lot size, and bedroom count. Income approach supports $1,200/mo rental value (GRM of ~5.2x). Assessed value of $9,520 appears below market.

About the property

Tenant-Occupied 3BR Colonial with Detached 2-Car Garage

This 1924 colonial at 10418 Sandusky Avenue is a tenant-occupied single-family residence in Cleveland’s Union-Miles Park that offers immediate rental income and clear restoration potential. The property contains 3 bedrooms and 1 bathroom across approximately 1,258 square feet of living area on a level 0.101-acre (4,400 sq ft) lot with 40 feet of street frontage. Noted interior elements include hardwood floors and a partially finished basement; utilities are municipal water and sewer with gas heating via forced-air. Cooling is not present.

The house is a two-story, frame construction with a shingle roof and a detached garage sized for two vehicles. Vehicular access is from a standard residential driveway on Sandusky Avenue. The detached garage and compact lot create straightforward opportunities for exterior repairs, driveway or landscaping work, and accessory improvements depending on project goals and local permitting.

From an investment perspective, the home is currently tenant-occupied and produces rental income with an estimated monthly rent of $1,200 (rent estimate based on local comparables). Historical sale activity shows recent transfers in 2024–2025 at notably lower price points (most recent recorded sale: February 24, 2025 at $20,000). A sales-comparison valuation approach using nearby transactions produces an estimated value range of $70,000–$80,000 with a midpoint of $75,000; comparable sales within 0.5 miles support that range. Key financial signals in the file include a gross rental yield estimate and a rental-per-square-foot benchmark derived from local lease comps.

Neighborhood context and market dynamics should factor into any acquisition or renovation plan. Union-Miles Park is described as a developing neighborhood with median home values up ~10% since 2020, moderated demand from investors and first-time buyers, and an estimated walkability score of 43/100. Local schools are rated below average in the dataset, and market metrics indicate a buyer’s market with roughly 3.5 months of inventory and an average days-on-market near 45 days. Required due diligence items called out in the analysis include confirming the extent of restorations needed, verifying tenant lease terms, and reviewing title and ownership history.

For investors and renovators, this property presents a straightforward rehabilitation thesis: secure possession or partner with the current tenant, scope and price necessary restorations, and align rental or resale plans with the documented neighborhood comps. The detached two-car garage, manageable lot, and clear comparables in the immediate area are practical starting points for a value-add investment strategy.

Comparable evidence

See the properties helping shape the valuation.

Comparable sales

01Sold price$75,000
Property address10318 Sandusky Ave, Cleveland, OH 44105
4 bed2 bath1,296 sq ftBuilt 20030.1 mi4,400 sq ft lot$57.9/SF
Sold Jun 15, 2025
Subject difference
  • 38 SF larger
  • 1 additional bedroom
  • 1 additional bathroom
  • Similar lot size
  • 79 years newer
Research comparison noteNewer construction, similar lot size, additional bedroom and bathroom
02Sold price$64,900
Property address10418 Way Ave, Cleveland, OH 44105
4 bed2 bath1,596 sq ftBuilt 19290.2 mi4,522 sq ft lot$40.7/SF
Sold Nov 18, 2023
Subject difference
  • 338 SF larger
  • 1 additional bedroom
  • 1 additional bathroom
  • Similar lot size
  • 5 years newer
Research comparison noteSimilar age and lot size, additional bedroom and bathroom
03Sold price$91,000
Property address10418 Reno Ave, Cleveland, OH 44105
4 bed2 bath1,536 sq ftBuilt 19240.3 mi5,200 sq ft lot$59.2/SF
Sold Mar 22, 2025
Subject difference
  • 278 SF larger
  • 1 additional bedroom
  • 1 additional bathroom
  • 800 SF larger lot
  • Same year built
Research comparison noteSimilar age, larger lot, additional bedroom and bathroom
Comp methodology: Focused on single-family homes within 0.5 miles in Union-Miles Park sold in last 12 months for maximum relevance
Property details

A 1924 colonial on 0.1 acres.

Building

Year built1924
ConstructionFrame
RoofShingle
Heatingforced_air_gas
Coolingnone

Site & utilities

Lot size0.101 acres
Garagedetached
Stories2
ConditionNeeds Restoration
BasementPartially Finished
FireplaceNo
Improvement notes3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, hardwood floors, partially finished basement
Lot area4,400 sq ft
TopographyLevel
Frontage40 ft frontage on Sandusky Avenue
ParkingGarage
Parking spaces2
Parking notesDetached garage with space for 2 vehicles
AccessStandard residential driveway from Sandusky Avenue
WaterMunicipal
SewerMunicipal
ElectricAvailable
GasAvailable
Location & nearby

Union-Miles Park

Researched nearby locations

John Adams College & Career Academy (0.5 mi)
Miles Park School (0.8 mi)
Union-Miles Park (1.2 mi)
Shaker Square Shopping Center (2.5 mi)

Location

10418 Sandusky Avenue, Cleveland, OH 44105

View in Google Maps
Editorial neighborhood context

Union-Miles Park is a developing residential neighborhood in eastern Cleveland with proximity to local schools and parks. The dataset cites John Adams College & Career Academy (0.5 mi), Miles Park School (0.8 mi), and Union-Miles Park (1.2 mi) as nearby anchors; Shaker Square and broader shopping are approximately 2.5 miles away. Median home values in the neighborhood rose roughly 10% from 2020–2025, while demographic notes show a one-mile median income near $35,000 and a population around 15,000. Local schools are recorded with below-average ratings, which may influence family-buyer demand.

Nearby access summary

Neighborhood green space access includes Union-Miles Park about 1.2 miles away, with additional neighborhood parks and recreational areas within a short drive. Shaker Square shopping and amenities are roughly 2.5 miles from the property.

ElementaryMiles Park School (3/10)
Middle schoolNathan Hale School (3/10)
High schoolJohn Adams College & Career Academy (3/10)
School districtCleveland Municipal School District
Market context

A factual market snapshot around 10418 Sandusky Avenue.

Median sale price$75,000
Avg days on market45 days
Inventory3.5 months
1-year appreciation2.0%
5-year appreciation10.0%
Zoning & land use

Two-Family Residential

Zoning

Zoning code2F
DescriptionTwo-Family Residential
JurisdictionCity of Cleveland
Assessor useSingle Family Residential
Current useResidential
SetbacksFront 30', side 5', rear 20'

Research-indicated uses

  • Single Family
  • Two Family
Verify with the jurisdiction: Zoning, setbacks, and allowed-use summaries are research indicators—not legal advice or a determination that a specific use is permitted.
Tax & sale history

Assessment data and recorded transactions.

Assessed value is kept visually separate from the CompCasa market-value estimate.

Tax assessment

Assessed land$3,080
Assessed improvements$6,440
Total assessed$9,520
Assessment year2025
Annual property tax$637
Tax year2025

Sale history

2025-02-24$20,000 · $15.9/SF
2024-08-30$20,400 · $16.2/SF
2018-06-20$23,100 · $18.4/SF
Rental market context

Rental references from the research record.

Context only—not an investment recommendation or guarantee of achievable rent.

Supporting lease references

01Monthly rent$1,325/mo
Property address10613 Sandusky Ave Unit B, Cleveland, OH 44105
3 bed2 bath1,802 sq ft$0.73/SF
Leased Aug 1, 2025
Subject difference
  • 544 SF larger
  • 1 additional bathroom
Research comparison noteLarger unit, additional bathroom, similar bedroom count
02Monthly rent$1,295/mo
Property address10409 Nelson Ave, Cleveland, OH 44105
3 bed1 bath960 sq ft$1.35/SF
Leased Jul 15, 2025
Subject difference
  • 298 SF smaller
Research comparison noteSmaller unit, similar bedroom and bathroom count
Research findings & due diligence

What the research supports — and what is still worth verifying.

Key findings

  • Property sold in February 2025 for $20,000
  • Assessed value $9,520 (land $3,080, improvements $6,440) — annual taxes $637
  • Zoned 2F — allows single-family and two-family residences
  • Comparable sales within 0.5 miles in last 12 months range $70K–$80K
  • Average days on market in Union-Miles Park: 45 days

Still worth verifying

Routine buyer due diligence items; these are not known defects.

  • Confirm extent of required restorations
  • Verify tenant lease terms and conditions
  • Assess local rental market conditions
  • Review title and ownership history
Highlights & features

What stands out about this property.

Interior Features

  • 3 bedrooms
  • 1 bathroom
  • Approx. 1,258 sq ft gross building area
  • Hardwood floors
  • Partially finished basement
  • Forced-air gas heating
  • No central air conditioning (cooling: none)
  • Shingle roof
  • Frame construction
  • 2 stories
  • Detached garage (2 vehicles)
  • Level lot, 4,400 sq ft (0.101 acres)
  • 40 ft frontage on Sandusky Avenue
Research transparency

Sources & research confidence.

See where the property research came from and how confidence varies by field.

View sources & confidence
1
Homes.com property details and ownership historyView source
2
Zillow listing and tax historyView source
3
Realtor.com property details and tax historyView source
4
Redfin comparable property detailsView source
5
Realtor.com comparable property detailsView source
Important: This analysis is AI-assisted and may contain inaccuracies. It is not a formal appraisal. Verify all critical facts with primary records, licensed professionals, and on-site inspection before making purchase decisions.