$725,000
4 Bed · 3.5 Bath · 1,990 Sq Ft
Historic 1930s farmhouse and 2013 main house with workshop and stream.
4
Beds
3.5
Baths
1,990
Sq Ft
2013
Built
4.77 acres
Lot
2-car attached
Garage
This estate announces itself by the land first: 4.77 private acres threaded by a small stream, a detached workshop, and two thoughtfully maintained dwellings — a modern 2013 main house and a character-rich farmhouse built in the 1930s. Walk the gravel drive and you’ll notice the practical metal roofs, vinyl siding on the main structure, and a sense of privacy set back from Chigger Ridge Road.
The main house (built 2013) favors open volume — vaulted ceilings, a wood-burning stove that anchors the living area, and an energy-conscious solar battery system. Systems are modern: heat pump cooling, central electric, propane-capable heating and a full basement for storage and future options. The attached 2-car garage plus driveway parking provides room for guests and toys. The smaller farmhouse has been updated with modern HVAC and presents a clear rental or guest-house opportunity: two bedrooms, one bath, and vintage bones that respond well to adaptive use.
Outside offers the kind of versatility buyers seek: sheltered spots for gardens, a workshop for projects, and forested boundaries that make the acreage feel expansive. Utilities are independent and rural—private well and septic—so long-term owners will appreciate the low-visibility setting and the stewardship benefits of acreage. With a combined living area of approximately 1,990 sq ft, the parcel comfortably supports multi-generational living, an income stream from the farmhouse, or an owner-occupied main house with guest accommodations.
Location is quietly advantageous. Downtown Sylva’s shops and restaurants sit about 3.5 miles away; Western Carolina University is roughly 7 miles, and scenic corridors like the Blue Ridge Parkway and Great Smoky Mountains are within easy weekend reach. For buyers seeking privacy without isolation, this property balances country living with community access. Call listing agent Pat Sluder for a private tour and to discuss the property’s options, rental history, and recent improvements.
Sutton Branch offers a rural, private character while remaining minutes from downtown Sylva’s cafes, groceries and community events. The neighborhood attracts buyers who prioritize acreage, quiet roads and natural surroundings — hikers, hobby farmers, and those affiliated with nearby Western Carolina University. Local life centers on outdoor recreation, seasonal festivals in Sylva, and small-town services; practical errands typically require a short drive. This area is popular with second-home buyers and retirees seeking a low-density lifestyle with access to regional trail systems and scenic drives.
Jackson County’s market is showing steady appreciation with a median sale price around $250,000 and measured growth of roughly 4% year-over-year and 15% over five years. Inventory sits at approximately 3.5 months with average days on market near 45 — conditions that favor well-priced, distinctive listings. Properties with acreage and dual-dwelling configurations tend to move differently than cookie-cutter suburban homes; they attract buyers seeking privacy, rental income, or land-use flexibility. Comparable sales in the immediate area include a nearby 2013 main house sale that supports the listing price per square foot of about $364. From a buyer’s perspective, this is a niche purchase: financing and inspection items (well, septic, and older-structure maintenance) deserve attention, but the demand for larger lots and separate living units makes this a timely opportunity for owner-occupiers and investors. Rental potential exists — a recent farmhouse rental on-site listed at $1,100/month — though gross rental yields are modest; the real value lies in versatility and long-term appreciation in this market segment.
Smoky Mountain High
High
Fairview Middle
Middle
Fairview Elementary
Elementary
Very good regional recreation access: Blue Ridge Parkway trailheads within about 10 miles, Great Smoky Mountains National Park about 15 miles away, plus local green spaces and university recreational activities nearby for hiking, biking, and weekend outdoor pursuits.
Unique property offering modern and historic residences on substantial private acreage, presenting both residential comfort and income potential in a desirable location.
Buyers should conduct independent due diligence before making any purchase decisions.
Low
$700K
Midpoint
$725K
High
$750K
$364/SF estimated price per square foot
Sales comparison approach using recent listings and sales in the area, adjusted for unique features and acreage. Income approach considers rental potential of the additional farmhouse.
As of 2026-03-08
This is a computer-generated estimate for informational purposes only and is not an appraisal or professional valuation.
Stable population with modest growth; area attracts retirees and second-home buyers.
Private setting with proximity to Sylva's amenities, educational institutions, and national parks.
Market data is based on aggregated public records and may not reflect real-time conditions.
Allowed Uses
$193/SF
Arm's length transaction
$24/SF
Historical sale
Claim this property page to feature your contact info and connect directly with buyers researching this address.
One-time fee. Your info appears on this page across CompCasa.
CompCasa is a marketing and technology platform. All brokerage services are provided by licensed partners.