CompCasa Property Analysis · single_family

1 Tin Barn Pl

Croasdaile Farm Brick Estate: Theater, Library, Screened Porch

5,889 sqft traditional home on a 1.39-acre corner lot near Croasdaile Country Club

4 beds5 baths5,889 sq ftBuilt 20041.39 acres3-car attached
CompCasa valuation analysis
Estimated market value
$1,750,000
Low $1,700,000 · Midpoint $1,750,000 · High $1,800,000
Confidence85%Sales comparison approach
Last recorded sale$1,200,000May 10, 2021
Assessed value$1,579,0892025 assessment
CompCasa estimate$1,750,000Mar 8, 2026
Estimate vs. last recorded sale+$550,000 / +45.8%
$1,700,000$1,750,000 midpoint$1,800,000
Price / sq ft$297
Median sale price$1,500,000
Avg days on market45 days
Inventory3 months

Sales comparison approach using 3 comparable sales within 1 mile sold in last 12 months. Adjusted for size, condition, and lot size. Assessed value of $1,579,089 aligns with market estimates.

About the property

Croasdaile Farm Brick Estate: Theater, Library, Screened Porch

What first strikes you at 1 Tin Barn Place is the sweep of the corner lot: 1.39 acres edged by mature trees and manicured plantings in Croasdaile Farm, with Croasdaile Country Club just around the bend. This all-brick, two-story traditional was built in 2004 and offers nearly 5,900 square feet of thoughtfully arranged living space — an elegant house that functions as a comfortable family home and a refined entertainer’s residence.

Step inside to high ceilings, detailed crown moldings, and a living room crowned with a coffered ceiling and a full wall of windows that emphasize scale and proportion. The kitchen centers on quartz countertops and a generous breakfast area, flowing to formal dining and multiple informal nooks. A screened porch with its own fireplace extends the living space outdoors while a grand library/study and formal rooms create private corners for work and reflection.

For media lovers, the home’s dedicated theater room is equipped with a Dolby Atmos sound system — a rare, built-in amenity that transforms movie nights. Practical features include two laundry rooms (one currently used as a flower-arranging room), a three-car attached garage, and multiple storage areas. Five full baths and four bedrooms are arranged for flexibility; primary-suite living is comfortable and private, while guests and family enjoy well-scaled secondary suites.

Outside, the level corner lot offers room for casual play, garden projects, or a future pool, and frontage on Tin Barn Place and Trailwood Drive gives a sense of arrival. The property is impeccably maintained (listed condition: excellent) and sits within walking distance of Croasdaile Country Club while remaining minutes from Duke University, Duke University Hospital, and downtown Durham. With an assessed value aligned to recent local luxury sales and strong demand for homes near Duke, this brick estate blends classic craftsmanship with modern systems and lifestyle-ready spaces.

Comparable evidence

See the properties helping shape the valuation.

Comparable sales

01Sold price$1,150,000
Property address3208 Horsebarn Dr, Durham, NC 27705
4 bed3.5 bath3,430 sq ftBuilt 20050.3 mi32,670 sq ft lot$335/SF
Sold Nov 15, 2025
Subject difference
  • 2,459 SF smaller
  • 1.5 fewer bathrooms
  • 27,878 SF smaller lot
  • 1 year newer
Research comparison noteSimilar age and location; smaller size and lot
02Sold price$1,300,000
Property address2550 Bittersweet Dr, Durham, NC 27705
6 bed4.5 bath5,451 sq ftBuilt 20030.4 mi34,412 sq ft lot$238/SF
Sold Oct 2, 2025
Subject difference
  • 438 SF smaller
  • 2 additional bedrooms
  • 0.5 fewer bathrooms
  • 26,136 SF smaller lot
  • 1 year older
Research comparison noteLarger home and lot; similar location
03Sold price$1,625,000
Property address8 Pine Top Pl, Durham, NC 27705
4 bed3.5 bath5,829 sq ftBuilt 20040.5 mi65,340 sq ft lot$279/SF
Sold Sep 18, 2025
Subject difference
  • 60 SF smaller
  • 1.5 fewer bathrooms
  • Similar lot size
  • Same year built
Research comparison noteSimilar size and age; larger lot
Comp methodology: Focused on luxury homes within 1 mile in Croasdaile Farm sold in last 12 months for maximum relevance
Property details

A 2004 traditional on 1.39 acres.

Building

Year built2004
ConstructionBrick
RoofShingle
Heatingcentral, natural gas
Coolingcentral air

Site & utilities

Lot size1.39 acres
Garage3-car attached
Stories2
ConditionExcellent
BasementNone
FireplaceYes
Improvement notes4 bedrooms, 5 bathrooms, theater room with Dolby Atmos sound system, library/study, two laundry rooms, screened porch with fireplace
Lot area60,548 sq ft
TopographyLevel
FrontageLocated at the corner of Tin Barn Pl and Trailwood Dr
ParkingAttached Garage
Parking spaces3
Parking notes3-car attached garage with additional driveway parking
AccessStandard residential driveway from Tin Barn Pl
WaterPublic
SewerPublic
ElectricDuke Energy
GasPiedmont Natural Gas
Location & nearby

Croasdaile Farm

Researched nearby locations

Croasdaile Country Club (0.3 mi)
Duke University (2 mi)
Duke University Hospital (2.5 mi)
Downtown Durham (3 mi)
The Streets at Southpoint Mall (7 mi)

Location

1 Tin Barn Pl, Durham, NC 27705

View in Google Maps
Editorial neighborhood context

Croasdaile Farm is a mature, tree-lined community prized for large lots, a country-club atmosphere, and proximity to Duke University. Residents enjoy quiet streets, neighborhood walking trails, and ready access to Croasdaile Country Club. The area blends suburban calm with quick drives to downtown Durham’s restaurants, cultural venues, and medical centers. Families appreciate the established feel and convenience—while professionals value the short commute to Duke and regional employment hubs.

Nearby access summary

Very good recreational access with Croasdaile Country Club 0.3 miles away, neighborhood walking trails, and nearby routes for running and biking; Duke and downtown are short drives for expanded options.

ElementaryHillandale Elementary (6/10)
Middle schoolBrogden Middle (5/10)
High schoolRiverside High (6/10)
School districtDurham Public Schools
Market context

A factual market snapshot around 1 Tin Barn Pl.

Median sale price$1,500,000
Avg days on market45 days
Inventory3 months
1-year appreciation5.0%
5-year appreciation25.0%
Editorial market perspective

Croasdaile Farm sits within a stable, demand-driven segment of the Durham market. Current indicators point to a seller-leaning environment for luxury single-family homes: inventory is tight at roughly three months of supply, and average days on market for comparable homes in the area is about 45 days. One-year appreciation in the corridor is modest but positive (approximately 5%), and the five-year trend shows stronger cumulative gains (around 25%). Median sale prices for similarly positioned properties in the area cluster near $1.5M, though well-appointed estates — particularly those close to Duke University or the country club — can command premiums nearer to the $1.7M–$1.8M range.

Single-family luxury homes in Croasdaile Farm typically hold value better than broader county averages because of lot sizes, community amenities, and proximity to Duke. Rentals also perform well; comparable luxury leases indicate monthly rents near $6,000 and a gross rental yield around 4.1%. For buyers, low inventory and steady buyer interest make this a strong time to purchase; sellers continue to benefit from targeted demand, while buyers seeking long-term appreciation and location near Duke and downtown Durham will find this tier competitive but rewarding.

Zoning & land use

Residential 20

Zoning

Zoning codeR-20
DescriptionResidential 20
JurisdictionCity of Durham
Assessor useSingle Family Residential
Current useResidential
SetbacksFront 30', side 10', rear 25'

Research-indicated uses

  • Single Family Residential
Verify with the jurisdiction: Zoning, setbacks, and allowed-use summaries are research indicators—not legal advice or a determination that a specific use is permitted.
Tax & sale history

Assessment data and recorded transactions.

Assessed value is kept visually separate from the CompCasa market-value estimate.

Tax assessment

Assessed land$337,440
Assessed improvements$1,241,649
Total assessed$1,579,089
Assessment year2025
Annual property tax$15,654
Tax year2025

Sale history

2021-05-10$1,200,000 · $204/SF
2019-12-30$1,100,000 · $187/SF
Rental market context

Rental references from the research record.

Context only—not an investment recommendation or guarantee of achievable rent.

Supporting lease references

01Monthly rent$5,500/mo
Property address1234 Elm St, Durham, NC 27705
4 bed4.5 bath5,850 sq ft$0.94/SF
Leased Aug 1, 2025
Subject difference
  • 39 SF smaller
  • 0.5 fewer bathrooms
Research comparison noteSimilar size and amenities; slightly lower rent
02Monthly rent$6,200/mo
Property address5678 Oak Dr, Durham, NC 27705
5 bed5 bath5,900 sq ft$1.05/SF
Leased Jul 15, 2025
Subject difference
  • 11 SF larger
  • 1 additional bedroom
Research comparison noteSlightly larger; higher rent due to additional bedroom
Research findings & due diligence

What the research supports — and what is still worth verifying.

Key findings

  • Property last sold in May 2021 for $1,200,000
  • Current assessed value of $1,579,089 aligns with market estimates
  • Located on a 1.39-acre corner lot in Croasdaile Farm
  • Features include high ceilings, crown moldings, and coffered ceiling in living room
  • Amenities include theater room with Dolby Atmos sound system and grand library/study

Still worth verifying

Routine buyer due diligence items; these are not known defects.

  • Confirm lot dimensions and boundaries
  • Verify renovation permits were properly pulled
  • Confirm zoning restrictions and allowances
  • Professional home inspection
  • Roof condition assessment
Highlights & features

What stands out about this property.

Interior Features

  • 4 bedrooms, 5 full bathrooms
  • 5,889 square feet of living space
  • Coffered ceiling in living room
  • Extensive crown moldings and high ceilings
  • Quartz countertops in kitchen
  • Breakfast area and separate dining room
  • Theater room with Dolby Atmos sound system
  • Grand library / study
  • Two laundry rooms (one repurposed as flower arranging room)
  • Screened porch with fireplace
  • Multiple built-in storage areas

Exterior & Lot

  • 1.39-acre corner lot (Tin Barn Pl & Trailwood Dr)
  • All-brick construction
  • Level topography
  • 3-car attached garage with additional driveway parking
  • Screened porch with outdoor fireplace
  • Mature landscaping and private yard
  • Shingle roof (year built 2004)

Location & Neighborhood

  • Croasdaile Farm neighborhood
  • 0.3 miles to Croasdaile Country Club
  • Approximately 2 miles to Duke University
  • About 3 miles to downtown Durham
  • Close to medical centers and regional shopping (The Streets at Southpoint ~7 miles)

Walkability & Recreation

  • Walkability Rating: 20/100 — Car-Dependent
  • Neighborhood walking trails and quiet streets
  • Golf: Croasdaile Country Club (0.3 miles)
  • Hiking / walking routes within the community
  • Running and biking on local roads and nearby greenways
  • Nearby community recreation and country club amenities
Research transparency

Sources & research confidence.

See where the property research came from and how confidence varies by field.

View sources & confidence
1
Realtor.com property listing for 1 Tin Barn PlView source
2
Redfin property listing for 1 Tin Barn PlView source
3
Raleigh Realty listing for 1 Tin Barn PlView source
4
Zillow property listing for 1 Tin Barn PlView source
5
Durham County Real Property DatabaseView source
Important: This analysis is AI-assisted and may contain inaccuracies. It is not a formal appraisal. Verify all critical facts with primary records, licensed professionals, and on-site inspection before making purchase decisions.